Supergroup Rock Dream Team Review

Click here if this is your business
5 / 5
From 1 review
100% of users recommend this
Click here if this is your business
  • Value For Money

garjen55's review of Supergroup Rock Dream Team


“Supergroup TV Pilot Concept: It's America vs. England...”

Written on: 15/09/2004 by garjen55 (1 review written)

Good Points
Fun website. Great idea for a TV show. Combines reality TV with music with philanthropy.

Bad Points
It's not an actual TV show and to get it on the air would require a lot of money and cooperation of many different companies.

General Comments
Supergroup TV Pilot Concept: It's America vs. England - the two countries that have contributed the most to Rock/Pop music. This is a Reality-based TV show featuring famous talented musicians forming a fantasy rock dream team in a music studio for a week or more to see what kind of album they can produce.

Obviously, to get these stars would require money, but here's the deal. Both Supergroups make and release albums and they share in the profits of their albums. Whichever group sells the most albums in a certain amount of time wins. The winning supergroup will get a million dollars each to donate to their favorite charity, plus a % of the album sales can go to charity as well. Also, the stars would receive an appearance payment commensurate with the profitability of the show.

Why this would work: Personally I haven't watched any reality shows so far because I don't care to see non-famous people eat worms (Fear Factor, Survivor) or date other desperate for fame people (dating shows, Bachelor). But shows like "Behind the Scenes" on VH1 intrigue people and there's no doubt that you put this many talented people with strong personalities in a studio together that there's going to be interesting conversation and conflicts. Plus we get to hear virtuoso musicians and genius songwriters craft their work and create songs that may be instant classics.

Will we be able to get everyone? No, but this concept will work with younger musicians also - members of the band Pearl Jam, Goo Goo Dolls, Dave Matthews, etc., for America, and members of Oasis, ColdPlay and U2 for the UK. The reason I want USA vs. UK is the fervor over the Ryder Cup is intense in Golf - even more so than the Olympics. Americans love the old UK bands like Beatles, Stones, Who, Clapton - so they would just as likely purchase the UK Supergroup album as they would the USA Supergroup album. Remember - the winner is decided by how many albums are bought - not by inaccurate voting on the Internet - or by judges with questionable opinions (American Idol). To host the show, I would like to get someone like Sheryl Crow.

In subsequent years, it doesn't have to be USA vs. UK - instead it can be men vs. women. A women supergroup consisting of Sheryl Crow on bass guitar, Bonnie Raitt on lead guitar, the drummer from The Corr's, Sarah McLachlan on piano, Melissa Etheridge on rhythm guitar. And then get a men Supergroup with popular artists from today. It definitely has to be that Supergroup concept where you take musicians that have made it on their own - but when join together into a Supergroup - magic can happen - or disaster - either way we're there to catch it on film.

The best thing about this TV show is that after you watch - you won't feel like you wasted your time. I can't tell you how many people have said they watched a reality show and afterwards felt like it was the biggest waste of time. With this show, if the musicians are in the same studio for 2 weeks and cameras roll continuously, I estimate that each day could be edited into one weekly episode. I think an hour show - the first half hour for England studio footage and the second half hour for USA studio footage. Fans will like the music, the personalities, the conflicts, the competition and the fact that it's benefiting charities.

  • Value For Money

If you are commenting on behalf of the company that has been reviewed, please consider upgrading to Official Business Response for higher impact replies.

Newamusements's Response to 170415_garjen55's Review

Written on: 14/10/2004

This is the worst idea for a reality TV show ever. First of all, there's a reason that stars of the magnitude you're suggesting don't go on reality TV programs - they're cheesy and they don't want to be made to look stupid.
<br>Second, the stars you're suggesting are horrifying. If the supergroups you suggest actually formed, I'd have to deafen myself deliberately to avoid the horribleness of what they'd do. It's bad enough with the lot of them recording separately. Together - it would be the 2 worst albums ever made!
<br>Third, when you couldn't get your first choices, and had to approach the likes of Noel Gallagher, Chris Martin and Bono, I suspect theat your probably wouldn't get past their PA's (except maybe Chris Martin, he's just the sort to actually do something this soul-destroying). These people have too much integrity to subject themselves to such a proposition, particularly when the finished result, especially if it was written and recorded in a week, would probably be AWFUL. I can hear the reaction of the Gallagher brothers in my head, in's too rude to type. You probably could, however, get a bunch of second-rate boyband chancers desperate for attention, and oh, wouldn't that be marvellous :P.
<br>There's no chance of anyone, EVER funding this project; but if there were, you just might, single-handedly manage to end music by creating 2 albums so awful that the world would turn off their radios FOREVER and mourn forever the day that, truly, the music died a slow, painful, tortured death.

Here's a better suggestion, why not just ask the record-buying, TV-watching public to give you money to NOT make a program like this and donate that money to charity instead?

Reply to this comment
If you are commenting on behalf of the company that has been reviewed, please consider upgrading to Official Business Response for higher impact replies.
Report this review
Was this review helpful? 0 0