written by HMD on 28/09/2005
I have the Citroen C4 automatic petrol version. The gearbox can be operated in fully auto mode which it does tolerably well if a little harsh on the gearchanges at times, or in a manual-shift mode as a clutchless change.
The manual mode is useful for shifting up early when driving gently to save fuel. However, the manual mode is maddening as the car takes over when you are not expecting it. For example, if you've shifted down into second in slow traffic, then start to accelerate away you might find the engine roaring like mad because it shifted itself into first gear, but doesn't want change up again. If the wretched thing wants to be called manual-mode, it should behave like it.
The reflections in the screen in bright sunshine can be dangerous. I have been in the situation where I couldn't see the nearside of the road through the reflection. The reflections are from the acre of plastic dash, in particular the central instrument console, exacerbated by the shallow slant angle of the windscreen The problem is not the colour of the plastic but its finish - it's too shiny. When I can find some black velvet, or similar, I shall stick it on all of the horizontal surface, the problem's so bad.
The suspension transmits far too much of the road surface at traffic speeds. At higher speeds, it all smooths out and is quite comfortable. My previous French cars were designed for rough French roads, but not this one, it seems.
Fuel consumption from the 1.6 litre engine (don't forget it's automatic) is about 36 -37 mpg about town, 41 mpg on long runs.
Rather wish I hadn't bought it now.
Do you have a question about this product or company? Simply type it in the box below and one of our community will give you an answer
Once we've checked over your question we will put it live on the site and our strong community of experts will hopefully give you some great answers that you find useful.
We will email you when the question is on the site
As rated by our community of reviewers
Rpetch's Response to HMD's Review
Written on: 04/03/2014
i also have the C4 sx Auto but i only get an average of 30 mpg doing half motorway and half town work. i have noticed that when it is in auto mode it will not change up untill it reaches at least 43 mph so i have to keep using the manual shift other than the mpg its a great car to drive but
Broadband Bill's Response to HMD's Review
Written on: 25/07/2017
The Citroen EGS gearbox takes a ittle time to appreciate. However, I suggest the effect you describe is caused more by lack of practise than a design problem.
I have driven the Audi DSG system which is slick in comparison, but mimicks the traditional auto box - e.g. it creeps forwards in drive mode when stationary, and backwards in reverse when stationary. The Audi will override the driver in manual mode, though, as you described above.
Citroen's EGS system is designed for someone who is used to manual boxes, and therefore will only move off the spot when the accelerator is pressed. This saves fuel and makes hill starts similar to a manual. In the same way, if driven in automatic mode, fuel savings will be made as it is designed to change gear optimally.
If you forget to change gear when in manual mode, the computer senses this to prevent stalling or lugging and changes down, or in the case of over revving it will change up, similar to the Audi.