I used MissCar Car Insurance for my daughter's insurance. She had tried all the usual suspects but couldn't get anything lower than her renewal. They only do woman car insurance - shame because they do seam to be cheap.

I first used MissCar Car Insurance to get an insurance quote for one of my daughters a few months ago.
They responded within around 2 hours which I felt was a little slow in ths technological age! When they did contact me it was first by personal email and then (I ticked the box!), by telephone.
This is the way they seem to work:
The small amount of questions that the quote form on the site asks for does not actually create a price. A real person telephoned me, asked a few more questions and then gave me the name and phone number of the company they were confident could give the best quote for my daughter's needs.
The subsequent quote, whilst not the absolute cheapest, was certainly a better deal than the best we had found so far.
Recently, my wife's policy came up for renewal. This time the response was a fair bit quicker and the company we were referred to (a direct insurer) was completely different to the one for my daughter.
Well done MissCar!