Report Abuse

Report this review to the Review Centre Team

Here at Review Centre we work hard to make sure we are the best place on the internet for honest, unbiased consumer reviews - we are grateful for your help in keeping us that way!


Why are you reporting this review?

If you represent this business why not claim your page by creating a Free Business Account where you will receive improved review monitoring functionality.


“Do not buy! It burns!”

Written on: 06/10/2015 by ajGrant1993 (1 review written)

I wanted to love this liner, I really did. The Super Liner Perfect Slim applies beautifully. Very thin, clean lines. The color is not as black as it could be, though. And it transfers to my lids (I even tried it with eyeshadow on top). But my biggest problem was the reaction on my skin.

I was about to chuck out my Too Faced Chocolate Bar palette, thinking that the sodium saccharine in it was the cause for the itchiness and burning sensation around the corner of my eyes and my crease. This and the liner were the only new makeup items I'd used plus I'm allergic to sulfas, after all, and as I've recently learned, the ss is a family member of the sulfas... Even if this particular ingredient never caused me problems in my toothpaste, for example. (I've since tried them again, and felt no discomfort). I thought for sure this little liner couldn't be it.

But then I tried the liner again with a different set of eyeshadows that I've used for years. I had to wash my face within a couple of hours. It was the same reaction all over again. It seriously burns and itches, its thoroughly painful. I had little painful bumps on my outer corners, a mild leftover itch on the crease where the liner transferred, a dark line where I lined my eyes (even after makeup remover + cleanser), and watering eyes; which is small compared to what others have experienced, now that I've seen the reviews, so I guess I was lucky. Even more so because now I can get rid of it immediately before the rashes turn worse.

I love L'oreal Paris mascaras and use other brands from its parent company like Lancome, Urban Decay, and Maybelline for skincare and makeup, too. But I think I'll stick with Revlon for liquid eyeliners from now on...

Greetings from Mexico!

Was this review helpful? 0 0