Having used many different liquid eyeliners, I have found this to be one of the worst, it flakes off very easily. Completely rubbish.

I like the applicator, and range but the actual liquid is awful.

It was very, very messy to apply. Maybelline Liner Express smudged easily and would occasionally cover my entire eyelid if I didn't apply a loose power before-hand/after. The color was fairly nice and dark. The pencil broke constantly. I paid eight dollars at a drugstore for this product and feel I've wasted my money. My main peeve is how it smudged too easily and would appear very light very quickly. Removal is okay, a bit better than trying to remove other eyeliners. I'd say no, don't buy this product.

Maybelline Liner Express is a great eyeliner! It goes on smooth, lasts fairly long, and looks great!