Use the tools below to refine your search by only displaying reviews with a certain number of star ratings or to only show reviews from a certain time period. Eg click on '1 star' to just display the reviews we have which received a 1 star rating click or 'Within the last month' to display just reviews posted over the last month.
Written on: 21/12/2015 by HillaryZ (3 reviews written)
This mascara is quite expensive, but the effect is not the expected one: the product is somewhat dry and messy. It also gets thick in less than a month. I expect more for the price… Read Full Review
Written on: 13/01/2013 by Aimeeeleanorl (1 review written)
I purchased the YSL false lash effect mascara (waterproof) at the same time as a YSL touché eclat. The touché eclat is amazing but the mascara was a complete waste of money. I paid over £20 for it and have used it three times then given up. It's very messy and very clumpy, just doesn't make my eyelashes look very good at all. It also smudged under my eyes within the first few hours, terrible. The brush always has too much product on it, meaning you have to wipe the excess with a tissue. I… Read Full Review
Written on: 29/10/2012
I bought it in a well known department store from a busy counter. Extremely dry and clumpy. Lid below my bottom lashes gets mascara stains very quickly, whatever the weather. Doesn't stay on for long. I love the brush and the golden colour, but very messy mascara… Read Full Review
Written on: 21/02/2010
Quite messy to put on, but once cleaned up with a cotton wool bud looks amazing...
...for a while. It makes my lashes feel very weighed down and the volume and curl drops out of them very quickly.
After I've had it on for about anhour, my eyes feel itchy and gritty and the next day the skin around them goes red and sore. I have NEVER been allergic to any other make up product in the past and I always get my make up off before going to bed.
I won't buy it again. There are better mascara's… Read Full Review
Written on: 03/02/2010
This mascara is incredible! I hav very thin wispy lashes, and have been wearing false lashes for a number of years - now i don't need to! It coats every lash and makes them long and thick. Easy to apply, easy to take off! It is expensive but it's worth it! (try feelunique.com for cheap beauty products, i got mine for £15) It looks nice in the gold tube and box,I think the packaging looking good always helps! Also, it smells fantastic! I will definately be buying it again… Read Full Review
Written on: 08/01/2010 by Mizz Inimitable (1 review written)
If you want a Mascara that lengthens each lash and results in making your eyes stand out beautifully. This is THE ONE!
I have tried so so sooooooo many different types of Mascaras, but i always come back to this. I love it.
A friend had recommended it to me for ages, i still didnt buy it. Lol I thought it was abit too pricey for a mascara, but my opinion changed when she leant it to me. A little sacrifice by paying a few more pounds, but DAMN does it makes your eylashes look mesmerizing!… Read Full Review
Written on: 13/10/2009
Have they changed something about this product? Have used this quite a few times and have been more than happy. However recently purchased this again and was very disappointed, did not seem to have the same effect. Did not seem to go on the same or make my eyelashes as long as when used previously.
Dont think i will bother purchasing this again, there are just as good, if not better products, from cheaper ranges. Will keep trying for my ultimate mascara, thought i had found it in this… Read Full Review
Written on: 25/03/2009 by falselashlass (1 review written)
Yves Saint Laurent False Lash Effect is a fantastic mascara, best on the market today!! Has a great long thick brush with intense thick black mascara that easily thickens and lengthens your lashes after 1 stroke, use 2 for maximum effect no more.. stays on all day, night. Ladies Falsh lash effect YOU GET!… Read Full Review
Written on: 15/02/2009
I'd recommend Yves Saint Laurent False Lash Effect of course!! Easy removal,increadibly long lashes!PERFECT!and trut me,i ve given lots of money on different mascaras such as chanel,estee,mac,dior,rubinstein… Read Full Review
Written on: 14/11/2008
You will not be disappointed if you buy this, fantastic product, you can buy it in Superdrug for £16.95 as well, bargain!! Everyone should own this!!… Read Full Review
Written on: 27/09/2008 by detomi (1 review written)
First tried Yves Saint Laurent False Lash Effect after reading another review, does what it says on the box. Takes my lashes from non-existence to long and lush with just two coats. Been asked so many times if I've had extensions to which my reply of no prompts 'wow, you've got lovely lashes'.
Still using this as I've tried so many mascaras and have not had the same result as ysl false effect, but still on the lookout for something that will give me the same result at a cheaper price… Read Full Review
Written on: 17/09/2008 by meelz (1 review written)
The life of the product seems extremely short. When used every day, I found that the actual make-up became gluggy and thick within 2 weeks of CORRECT use.
If the product lasted longer then I think I would buy it again. I feel it is quite expensive for the short period of time it was usable… Read Full Review
Written on: 30/07/2008
I wouldn't believe the negative statements - I think this is the best mascara on the market. Easy to get off, amazing results - the only thing I worry about is having my lashes too long! It is expensive - but no more than other top level products… Read Full Review
Written on: 28/07/2008 by Skyebeauty (12 reviews written)
Yves Saint Laurent False Lash Effect - WOW This mascara does wonders! Can't believe I've finally found my perfect Mascara!
Its taken me so long to find a decent mascara that suits my poor (and pathetic excuse for) eyelashes. It lengthens all of my lashes (including the smaller lashes you wouldn't normally see), clearly defines and seperates and curls to create a full fan of femenine lashes.
This mascara does exactly what it says its meant to do. It does not flake, smear or smudge, and lasts… Read Full Review
Written on: 07/06/2008
I wouldn't try this its a waste of your hard earned money. When I spoke to an advisor on the YSL counter she advised me to clean the brush with a tissue which I did and it didn't change its performance… Read Full Review
Written on: 09/05/2008
Was very disappointed with this mascara, everyone raves about it so I thought I couldn't go wrong! The brush is really soft and doesn't do much to my lashes unless I sit for ages. It is quite messy as well, it goes on very wet. Can't believe people pay £19 for it. You would be much better off with LOreal Telescopic!… Read Full Review
Written on: 02/03/2008
Yves Saint Laurent False Lash Effect mascara is the ultimate beauty secret!… Read Full Review
Written on: 31/12/2007 by jenjam (1 review written)
I have very, very light eyelashes which look almost none existant without mascara. Every time I purchase a new mascara I hope that it will make my lashes long and fluttery and end up bitterly disappointed. My partner bought me this mascara after he saw a review on TV and I have to say WOW! This is without doubt the BEST mascara I have ever used. It left my eyelashes looking long and flirty, they were evenly separated and not clogged at all and the mascara smelt divine. My partner was blown away… Read Full Review
As rated by our community of reviewers
" Does as it promises :) " Read More
" Nice for certain lashes " Read More
" This mascara is quite expensive, but the effect is not the expected... " Read More
Written by HillaryZ
" Worst mascara ever bought " Read More
" Bad Gal Lash is Bad Ass " Read More