Have a picture of Bowling For Columbine?, please send it to us.
| Value for Money | 8/10  |
|---|---|
| Overall rating | 9/10 |
| Bowling For Columbine [2002] |  | £4.98P&P: £1.46 |
| Bowling For Columbine : Special Edition (Two Disc Set) [2002] | | £5.98P&P: £1.46 |
Full review by
steerpyke
on 28th Dec 2004
User Rating : 8
Respect :
0
Good Points: Fascinating insight into American gun culture
Bad Points: It's Moore, so it's left-wing and designed to sensationalize
General comments: Bowling For Columbine - Michael Moore has a way of presenting the facts in such a way that he doesn`t have to force the point home, he lets the audience draw the conclusion he wants them to. The opening segment of Bowling For Columbine is the perfect example of this. Only in America could you find a bank that offers you a free gun when you open an account with them. Standing in the lobby of the bank with his rifle in hand he asks the bank staff the obvious question, "don't you think that it's a bit dangerous handing out guns in a bank?" The film then follows a path that highlights the attitudes and absurdities of the Americans' view towards guns. The title relates to the school in Littlerock, Colorado were 12 students and one teacher were killed by two youths with legally and easily purchased guns.
Moore tackles a subject that he knows about, as a youth he was a prize winning marksman and is still a member of the National Rifle Association. He is also a native of Michigan, the same home state of Charlton Heston, NRA president and also Oklahoma bomber, Timothy McVey. The film is made with a mixture of humour and shock, but for the most part the film is a series of interviews with relevant parties from both sides of the gun issue. Talking first to the Michigan Militia, a group of gun enthusiasts, you get an idea of just how some Americans feel towards guns. Fair enough the Constitution gives the right to bear arms, but to what end, one man felt that an M16 was a suitable home defense weapon, and Moore jokingly wants to know if weapons grade plutonium is a suitable defence item to have to hand to use against the would be intruder. And that sums up part of the film's point, what is the acceptable level of personal arms.
The other main drive of the film is why does America have such a high gun murder rate. For example, the UK has a gun death rate of 68 per year, most European countries have similar levels, America's gun death rate is 11,127. So why is it so high? Various factors are examined, violent films, music, decline of family values and all of these are dismissed as being things that are common to all modern countries. Japan has more violent films, Germany has a more violent history, the UK has more broken homes, so what makes the USA so different.
The interviews in the film are very telling. Marilyn Manson was widely blamed for causing the Colombine High School killings, in that his music was influential and had adverse affects upon the youths that caused the massacre. As is pointed out, one hour before the Colombine tragedy was reported on the news, the main story was of the bombing of a hospital in Kosovo by American planes. Who is having a bigger influence on people, says Manson, me or the President? Charlton Heston and the NRA do not come off very well in Moore's interview, mainly through Heston's insistance to hold pro-gun rallys in locations soon after gun tragedies have occured. His interview is also very telling for what he almost says and his quitting the interview.
Moore uses techniques familliar to his other films, one of the most striking is a sequence of newsreel showing war and devastation with chilling statistics being shown over the top whilst Wonderful World plays out in the background. There is a marvellous South Park style cartoon history of American gun interests. This highlights what he sees as the main problem, fear. In a society that seems to fear and hate one another and with the media using sensationalism to get ratings, is this the type of society where guns should be easily available.
One of the most shocking pieces is the actual CCTV footage from Colombine High School, showing the shootings, and the distraught interviews with the survivors. This is powerful stuff and if it is Moore playing the shock card, at least it makes his point and leaves a lasting image with the viewer.
It's not a film for the easily shocked and could leave some people upset, but then the subject matter is a difficult one to chose and not deliver in a shocking way. It is Moore doing what he does best and is a must for anyone concerned about the gun issue.
If guns made the world a safer place, then America would be the safest place in the world.
steerpyke's review and ratings | 776 words
Review by
Ironmonkey
on 15th Oct 2003
User Rating : 10
Respect :
0
This Movie is a really good movie. I haven't seen a better documentary than this. It has some really funny cartoons and shows a good point about guns.
Ironmonkey's full review | 28 words
Would you like to see a review that's not being listed?
