| Value for Money | 6/10  |
|---|---|
| Reviewer Rating | 5/10 |
| Overall Rating | 6.7/10  |
Full review by
amazin
on 28th Mar 2007
User Rating : 5
Respect :
0
Good Points: What is correct is clear enough, though prolonged and needlessly complicated.
Bad Points: The new edition includes incorrect grammar, which mars an otherwise simple task.
General comments: The inclusion of incorrect grammar only disrupts the study of what is a very simple yet comprehensive language, and only confuses its students.
Do you teach that two plus two equals three? - Then why break the simple rules of this language which, in essence, consists of merely half a dozen clear and simple injunctions, with a few minor explanations to make it absolutely clear, particularly to Latin-speakers?
I used to recommend Murphy's as the best all-round grammar book, but the re-edition has included much that is incorrect, and my criticism here reflects that.
Why add unnecessary complication? This is a supposed to be a grammar book, not an illustration of the harm that has been done to the language consistently by these and other publishers over recent decades.
It would be an error of judgement to distort any subject in its teaching if this were not perhaps the conscious intention of the publishers.
amazin's review and ratings | 176 words
Would you like to see a review that's not being listed?
