Charles Dickens, The Signalman & Other Ghost Stories Reviews

Janet Lewison's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Report this review

Dickens' story The Signalman tantalises as it slips away from the reader's attempted grasp at 'truth'. For where is 'truth' in this story? Should we believe the fears of the lonely, isolated signalman who believes he is being haunted by a figure of nemesis foretellling death and destruction? Or should we view such terrible, repetitions of horror as the symptoms of a sick dis-eased mind, and cling to the rational observations of the unnamed narrator and visitor to the signalman's solitary world?

My son is studying this text for his English Literature GCSE and I am very grateful to have a reason to reread this text which refuses to declare its full significance and which evades our ability to locate and name 'truth'.

My first assumption centred around a dislike of the narrator who seemed a rather malignant interloper into the crypt-like wolrd of the signalman. The narrator's words ironically mirror those of the signalman's nemesis and it seemed quite possible to this reader that the narrator IS the nemesis without perhaps even realising this in any conscious or direct way.

I do wonder too at Dickens' superb ability to explore the tension between repetition and coincidence, and the ambivalence of coinicidence when it becomes symbolically retranslated by an unnerved mind, as fate. Lives are riddled by patterns( and our desire to discern and recognise patterns) and in this story the bemused and bedevilled signalman finds the revisitations of both nemesis and narrator so unsettling that it seems he chooses to embrace the certainty of literal extinction rather than the mentally destabilising uncertainty of progressive mental terror.

Dickens' The Signalman, as the story's title insinuates, explores the lonely predicament of a railway worker whose daily rituals are primarily concerned with safety. His literal 'signals' avert death. Yet the story's dramatic irony reveals the strange 'signals' that the story's protagonist appears to be receiving from a source unknown; revenant perhaps or just misunderstood manifestations of a lonely mind?

The extract above is taken from the opening of the story and I love the disorientating feel of the setting. Where is the narrator and where is the signalman? And how are these geographical positions crucial to our understanding of the story and even its possible resolution? For the dark, deep crypt-like situation of the signalman with the damp, gloomy apsect is suggestive of hell, of a 'fallen' post Edenic world. Such a setting is mirrored by the feverish quality of the signalman's words, who attaches a disturbing fatalism to the actions and utterances of the haunting figure. If Dickens' did rightly ( from direct experience of a railway crash) attach considerable danger to Victorian Industrialisation and railway system, then the sinister, monstruous appearance of the steam train hurtling out of its dark, tunnel-lair fulfils many Freudian nightmares as well as contrasting the inhuman and mechanistic against the malleable and human.

The powerful irony of the first utterance of the tale, encapsulates the dilemna and problem of the tale. Who is 'down there' and why is such an utterance shared between several figures, all contributing inevitably to the destruction of the signalman himself? ( who has been lowered into this pit by circumstance and social failure).

I love the playfulness of the title. What are signals after all? Can a signal exist without an audience and even translator? And is it merely a sign of the signalman's mental disorientation that he seeks the origin of the voice in the tunnel or is it in fact a gesture more revealing of the narrator's sinister duplicity? In other words, who can we trust to tell us where the origin of truth lies?! Everything in the story is created for us by the narrator. Could he create himself to suit his story? Of course! And part of the game of the tale is its slipperiness. Its meaning always seems to slip away, to evade us.

The Signalman is afterall a tale of narrative incarceration and entrapment....whatever you decide you know it is your decision and that other versions or readings haunt every turn of the tale.

How provocative the existential question:

"Is there any path by which I can come down and speak to you?"

What an ironic metaphor!

What is the answer and who can really respond to this almost Faustian question! Would you follow such a path?

Guest's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Report this review

i loved the story and i am going to buy this Dickens collection in hardback as well its awsome. loved the suspense the story held.

Guest's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Report this review

Although it's hard language, it's characters are like they are real. When i was reading i could easly image that position which is in book...

brendan booker's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Report this review

I didn't understand it atall to be completely honest withyou but the words will blow your mind! I loved it, it was a success to H.G.Wells! Buy a copy now! You are missing out big time.

Guest's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Report this review

The story gives a clear view of what a mystery and suspense story should be like. After reading the book I would have happily read a second one if there was one. Charles Dickens grabbed my attention and I found reading it at night is terrifying.

anita13's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Report this review

Charles Dickens, The Signalman & Other Ghost Stories - The book gives a good insight into the characters - it suggests that the traveller has been ill or has had some medical experience by the way that he speaks and it also shows the signalman's fear of the spectre in the way that he talks and moves.

adina's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Report this review

Charles Dickens, The Signalman & Other Ghost Stories - I found this collection of stories very typical of Dickens' style. Very clever and well thought out but altogether a bit too dry and without feeling. I found that the author's great manipulation of language and thorough development of plot, characters, and setting were very effective in creating tension and suspense for me, but became tiresome and were overly analytical and somewhat killed the mystical and supernatural feeling that the stori ...