- Review Centre
- Motoring
- Car Reviews
- 4x4
- BMW X5 4.4i Sport
- Overview
Have a picture of BMW X5 4.4i Sport?, please send it to us.
Picture courtesy of Henrik Ohm Eriksen.
| Performance | 9/10   |
|---|---|
| Practicality | 8/10 |
| Reliability | 1/10 |
| Value for Money | 5.5/10 |
| Reviewer Rating | 6/10 |
| Overall Rating | 4.6/10 |
Full review by
JMaldenham
on 5th Sep 2007
User Rating : 3
Respect :
0
Good Points: Tremendous handling. Great performance. Good steering feedback. Practical 5 door estate configuration.
Bad Points: To quote an independent professional IE What Car ---- " ferociously expensive to own" I would agree entirely & add the following to qualify my comment. On the question of very poor transmissions/gearboxes. Mine was too urgent when pulling away from stationary, then shutting down & going into safe home mode on an intermittent basis. Two BMW dealers failed to diagnose the problem. One BMW dealer stated that there was a communication problem between the traction control & the gearbox but could not pin point the problem. The other BMW dealer that they could not find the problem & keep driving it. Sadly the gearbox failed shortly afterwards quite dramatically & dangerously. Cost £4600 from BMW, around £2000 from a UK reconditioning companies. I have learned from forums in the UK & USA & UK Gearbox re-conditioners that there are problems with the ZF gearboxes. My car had a full BMW service history, had covered 70 odd thousand miles when the defect started to occur & failed at 80000 with collapsed bearings & other premature wear issues. There is an upgrade available to the rebuilders ie that of bearings etc & enough evidence on this site & other forums to act as third party comment. Suspension maintenance costs are beyond comparison with any other 4x4 I have had ie Range Rover or Lexus. The cost over the last 18 months & 10 000 miles has been over £1000 & yes the parts now are on "Back Order" I am advised by BMW so more down time!
General comments: I am a qualified Mechanical & Non destructive Testing Engineer who went on to be a board member managing procurement on a 57,000 vehicle fleet in Europe & have many years experience in global transportation, manufacture & maintenance facilities.
Over the last 15 years I have owned/been the daily user of the following cars:
1 Alfa Romeo Saloon, 3 BMW saloons, 1 Mercedes Coupe, 1 Lexus RX300, 1 Lexus LS400, 1 Range Rover & 1 Audi A8 & I have never had such an unreliable car that cost so much to maintain as my BMW X5.
In summary:
1.Some of the BMW X5 gearboxes have real reliability problems
2.Dealership service standards are appalling when compared with Audi & Lexus.
3.BMW X5 maintenance costs are to quote What Car Magazine again "ferociously expensive to own"
I'll pay another suspension bill tomorrow that will be in the region of £500 to £600 for it to pass an MOT!
Then I'll advertise the BMW X5 & go back to driving my Lexus which hasn't failed on a thing despite being 10 years old!
JMaldenham's review and ratings | 408 words
Review by
pnadin
on 12th Jun 2006
User Rating : 9
Respect :
-1
We test drove the Porsche Cayenne and the BMW X5 back to back and thought the X5 was a much better drive, handled better and was considerably cheaper for a higher spec model of the same age and mileage.
Ours has the panoramic sunroof which is a great feature for taking advantage of what little sun we do get.
The engine is superb, making great noises and having lots of grunt.
Recommended.
pnadin's full review | 85 words
