Mini Cooper S Reviews
Latest Reviews
★☆☆☆☆
“Nice perfomance bad handling”
Written on: 24/12/2012 by Nonegiven (2 reviews written)
I would like to know what other cars the reviewers have driven? I have never driven a car that handles so badly in my life and I have driven lots of cars. I would not risk my life taking a mini round the corner at high speeds. A ford focus zetec mk2 handles 100% better than a mini. The perfmance is fantastic but it is of no use with such poor handling. Some cars handle better than they perform but others like the mino perform better than the handle and that is the worst thing a car can do.... (read more)
★★★★☆
“Best car I've owned - 2011 Cooper”
Written on: 28/04/2012
I LOVE this car.. the only thing that bothers me is the hesitation I'm finding between gears (automatic). I'm used to a 6 cylinder so that may have something to do with it but EVERYTHING else is GREAT. I also splurged on the cooper connect (which is the new iphone connection with nav screen on the center counsel). It was well worth it (since i'm an iPhone addict). I have had the car nearly a year now and filled it up probably once... JK! I love the milage on this thing... i went from... (read more)
★★★☆☆
“great drive but poor design”
Written on: 29/02/2012
Don't get me wrong I love driving my 2010 mini clubman S and I love the way it looks. I have to say a major deterrent for repurchasing the same model is to never get the performance package !!!!! The front bumper is soooooo low that when I pull out of my driveway which is very low, the bumper has come off 3 times and one time pulled the sensor completely off so I was not able to get any airconditioning. I went over a pot hole and the entire front bumper cracked in half and I had to pay... (read more)
★★★★★
“Bought my brand spanking new 2011 mini cooper s 2...”
Written on: 29/04/2011
Bought my brand spanking new 2011 mini cooper s 2 months ago (R56). Live in Cape Town, South Africa. Pity our fuel is so expensive...this car wants to be driven. It shouts at me for cruising about and screams to drive it hard. Though rather fuel efficient if driven conservatively, but who cares, it brings about a smile when i approach it, when i enter the cockpit it yells at me to start it and when i drive it, it asks to embrace the fear factor, cause it sticks to the tar on bends, on tight... (read more)
★★★★★
“I love the Mini Cooper S. I race it and it can keep...”
Written on: 06/10/2009
I love the Mini Cooper S. I race it and it can keep up with the high hp cars on the turns and even pass them. It does lack on the streight aways though. That is something you should work on. Many girls at my school think it is "cuite" and "great size". If you are looking for a car that gets great mileage, take turns like a gocart, and a great price. Mini Cooper S is your choice. Watch "The Italian Job" and you will know what a Mini cooper S can handle. I love this car and I will never... (read more)
★★★★☆
“Purchased my '05 convertable one year ago, and I have...”
Written on: 14/09/2009
Purchased my '05 convertable one year ago, and I have absolutely loved it. The roof started leaking this week, and sadly the warranty expired two weeks ago. I hope that I still love this car after I get an estimate for having the roof fixed! (read more)
★★★★★
“The best car I've ever driven.period. I've driven lots...”
Written on: 07/05/2009
The best car I've ever driven.period. I've driven lots of sports cars but the MINI Cooper S is the only car which you can drive with confidence whilst travelling at speed. The handling is just amazing, the steering works as quick as you can move your arms. I've driven cars with crazy accelaration, much faster than the Cooper S, but I would still choose a Cooper S; its good on fuel, quick, low road tax, stylish ..and above all, fun. (read more)
★★★★☆
“The mini cooper S is a great car for those who want to...”
Written on: 01/04/2009 by nintendonut
The mini cooper S is a great car for those who want to have fun driving down country lanes and also want a practical commuter car. The build quality is great although the centre console does creak when cold.
Mini's aren't cheap but the residuals mean that when you do come to sell it you aren't going to lose a great deal. With BMW build quality bits aren't going to fall off along the way either.
This is the Mk1 BMW mini so it is the supercharged version. Whilst this gives you great...
(read more)
★★★★★
“When I was much younger I owned a 63 Morris Cooper S...”
Written on: 29/03/2009 by WORKSS (1 review written)
When I was much younger I owned a 63 Morris Cooper S and when BMW built the new Mini it was love at first site for me.
I bought my Works Cooper S in May of 2004 and now have approximately 80,000 trouble free and totally enjoyable miles on it. I have had a 17 % under drive pulley fitted and still manage to obtain a constant 30 MPG. The only problem I have had is keeping tires on the front of it due to a lead right foot. As we have other larger vehicles we removed the rear seat and made a flat...
(read more)
★★★★☆
“Had my Mini Cooper S now three years and it has been a...”
Written on: 26/02/2009 by speakout (86 reviews written)
Had my Mini Cooper S now three years and it has been a great car to drive and nothing has gone wrong with it (so far). It's handling is the best thing about it and I liken it to a big go-kart as it does take corners superbly. Long journeys are great in it which I was a little sceptical about it when I first bought it as I though I might feel cramped etc but the seats provide excellent support.
The stereo provides great sound. When I bought the car I had the iPod connector fitted which has...
(read more)
See next 10 reviews
Showing 1 - 10 of 70 Reviews
★★★★★
“I have owned a lot of cars and this is definately the...”
Written on: 19/11/2008 by adrenalin123 (2 reviews written)
I have owned a lot of cars and this is definately the most enjoyable to drive. For it's size it is a little on the thirsty side. You can't fit a bike rack on it easily (minor point). Mine is 4 years old but it still feels rock solid. (read more)
★★★★★
“Comfortable, not as bad as people have previously said...”
Written on: 11/11/2008
Comfortable, not as bad as people have previously said it is on fuel (and I do not drive slow), great looking car and can leave a lot of cars standing"!
Love the car looks great really fun to drive and very fast.
(read more)
★★★★★
“Love it! The Mini Cooper has good steering, great...”
Written on: 13/07/2008 by cm101 (1 review written)
Love it! The Mini Cooper has good steering, great handling, amazing feel inside and out, great accesories and is fun to drive! (read more)
★★★★★
“As a lifelong Mini enthusiast, I suppose I am biased,...”
Written on: 27/04/2008 by socram13 (9 reviews written)
As a lifelong Mini enthusiast, I suppose I am biased, having always had at least one Mini since early 1963. These have covere every thing from the Minivan, through modified 850cc, 998 Cooper and highly modified Cooper S - original type. Though that rip-snorting original S was a wonderful car, the modern S is so much morecompetent.
Brakes are just stunning with local tests showing a stop from 100kph to zero in about 26 metres.
Unfortunately, local speed limits and traffic reinforcement means...
(read more)
★★★★★
“Best car I have owned and I have owned quite a few. I...”
Written on: 15/03/2008
Best car I have owned and I have owned quite a few. I bought my Cooper S with loads of extras on it in Belfast and saved a couple of grand and BMW taxed it for 6 months and paid for the ferry travel over so I was well happy. I think the car is expensive and I actually never set out to buy one, I just came across it whilst working in Belfast, test drove it and it would have been rude to leave it behind. I didn't have a clue how much the insurance was and my dad insured it for me at the... (read more)
★★☆☆☆
“The mini is a great car to drive and I may have been...”
Written on: 16/01/2008 by booths (1 review written)
The mini is a great car to drive and I may have been unlucky with the amount of problems experienced in the first few weeks of ownership but did have the opportunity to test drive three courtesy cars while mine was in for repair a cooper, coopers and diesel and all had dash rattles.
Feel now that mini is over hyped and over priced being much cheaper to buy in America even though being assembled in the UK ,and the build quality and customer service poor in my experience,you may be luckier but...
(read more)
★★★★★
“This is the first Mini Cooper I have owned, I have...”
Written on: 24/07/2007 by Mini Man 07
This is the first Mini Cooper I have owned, I have loved their style ever since watching "The Italian Job" for the first time. It has lived up to all my expectations. I had rented one a little over a year ago, except it was a 2005 Mini Cooper S Diesel and even then, it had plenty of power. The handling and power are awesome, I have only had the wheels slip once and that was at a take off on wet pavement with the Sport button engaged, and it was a little more than normal acceleration. Parking... (read more)
★★★★★
“Just over a year ago I changed my BMW 545 4.5 litre...”
Written on: 15/01/2007 by tonybelcher (1 review written)
Just over a year ago I changed my BMW 545 4.5 litre for a Mini Cooper S with all the extras including Sat Nav, Bluetooth telephone etc. - It cost £22,000 in all and was worth every penny.
The car certainly has the GRIN factor - I've done 22,000 trouble free miles and enjoyed every minute. The BMW 545 was obviously faster, more comfortable and performed very well but it didn't have that man with machine feel, in fact it was a bit like driving a fast feather bed. WOW the Mini is great.
I...
(read more)
★★★★★
“The Mini Cooper S convertible is without doubt the...”
Written on: 02/10/2006 by Australiafelix (1 review written)
The Mini Cooper S convertible is without doubt the most hilarious car I ever owned. When I hit a kangaroo in my SL600 it cost me $28000 to fix. In the Mini you just steer around it no matter how fast you're going. Not rip snortingly fast in a straight line, but plenty fast enough, and if you can find a better handling car for under a hundred grand, let me know. Oh, and the roof doesn't leak. (Porsche, take note.) Also, note To Mini - how about a 3 litre V6 and four wheel drive? Your first... (read more)
★★★★☆
“"My other car is a Lotus" - as they say. An Elan S2 to...”
Written on: 17/08/2006 by Chriswise (1 review written)
"My other car is a Lotus" - as they say. An Elan S2 to be precise. And while I didn't expect the Mini to match the fun of driving that, I have to say I've been in the Cooper S every day since I bought it. It's very easy to live with - but still fun to drive. And even though there are thousands of them on the roads, there are zillions of accessories and options to ensure you can still have a pretty unique vehicle - or at least one that suits you down to the ground. The ONLY thing that lets... (read more)
See next 10 reviews
Showing 11 - 20 of 70 Reviews
★★★☆☆
“When we did have the Mini Cooper S, being a bloke, I...”
Written on: 09/07/2006 by decy
When we did have the Mini Cooper S, being a bloke, I thought I'd take it for a spin without the girlfriend. This is a very fast car and I've always driven fast cars. I owned an Audi Coupe and this is a faster car, It isn't that hard on fuel but then again we haven't had it long enough to give it a good long test drive. It's still with the dealership, it was overheating so they have replaced the water bottle, a sensor, the radiator, head gasket, thermostat, so at the min. not sure if it is... (read more)
★★★★★
“I always enjoy making grocery runs in the Mini Cooper...”
Written on: 09/05/2006 by goohamonsta
I always enjoy making grocery runs in the Mini Cooper S, just to get behind the wheel. The interior is pretty neat, like a retro spaceship, but as said above, it has a lot of rattles. If necessary, you can fold down the rear seats, and the little MINI can actually hold a fair amount of cargo. Ive been able to fit an entire drum set in there. We had a warning light on the dash, and drove it down to Bob Smith BMW/MINI in LA. It was supposed to take less than an hour to fix the light, but... (read more)
Tonybelcher's Response to 242083_goohamonsta's Review
Written on: 10/02/2007
The rattles have gone on the later models. My 2005 Mini Cooper S is as quiet as a mouse, with not a single rattle.
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“I bought a Dark silver Mini Cooper S with the Chilli...”
Written on: 03/04/2006 by jonboydavies (1 review written)
I bought a Dark silver Mini Cooper S with the Chilli pack through the Mini cherished scheme at Rydale Cardiff with 28500 miles on the clock this March. Overall very happy with it although it costs a bit more to run than my previous N reg Mini Cooper! Rydale Cardiff offered an excellent car at a competitive price, gave me a great part ex price and 6 months tax. A very pleasing deal all in all. The car has developed a few faults in the 3 weeks I've owned it, a rattling noise that turned out to... (read more)
★★★★★
“I have had my Mini Cooper S for 4 weeks now. I'm very...”
Written on: 13/02/2006 by rickmate
I have had my Mini Cooper S for 4 weeks now. I'm very impressed by the handling and the drive, and the feel of quality. Before this I owned a Lotus Elise so the change was very different, but I was not disappointed. The car is great fun and quick(ok not Elise quick but good)so far nothing has gone wrong. Hopefully to stay that way, my company does a lot of work for Lotus cars so I have a good understanding of good cars. The only down thing I would say is the price of a Mini Cooper S, also... (read more)
★★☆☆☆
“Having happily run a 2003 Mini Cooper S for 2 years...”
Written on: 20/12/2005 by jeclarke
Having happily run a 2003 Mini Cooper S for 2 years we've just bought a 2006 model and it is the most unreliable vehicle we have ever owned. Of the 80 days since registration it has been at the dealers almost 40 days with assorted mechanical, electrical, trim and paint problems. The most serious faults resulted in the car cutting out at speed on the motorway due first to a faulty engine module and then (2 weeks later) a failed oil recirculation valve. We're now selling the car as we just... (read more)
★★★★★
“Being a 'seasoned driver' - I've owned (1st car) 66...”
Written on: 17/12/2005 by shopdog (1 review written)
Being a 'seasoned driver' - I've owned (1st car) 66 Triumph Spitfire, 3 Alfa Romeos (2 Spyders, 1 Berlina), 2 Nissan 280 Zs, 3 Mazda RX7 (including 93 twin turbo), 3 Miatas, Beck Spyder (Porsche 550 clone but faster), Porche Boxter, and now the 06 Mini S.
The Mini is the best buy for the buck. The fun factor of this car is extraordinary. It is a small, torquey, quick as a racing kart (which I did for years) fun car. If it holds together, I'll keep it forever. These cars are not for...
(read more)
236196_Adolfh's Response to shopdog's Review
Written on: 28/03/2006
well sir i will have you know i have owned two ladas one scoda, old style, two fiat pandas one of which had a hub cap, a morris minor, i raced carts back in nam and find the new mini to be rather predictable and a touch feminine. i find your review to be lacking in expertise. if i could reccomend a fine machine that would tickle any true motoring fanatics fancy it would have to be a mint condish volvo 240 g reg. this mechanical masterpiece has been at the fore front of dynamic design and innovation for generations and handles like david seaman. please readers only digest good info from true motorists like myself and not a yupee alfa owner. sincerely adolf.
Reply to this comment
247145_Ntplano's Response to shopdog's Review
Written on: 14/06/2006
So, is this Volvo sports car available in the U.S.? I, myself would compare the fun factor of the Mini Cooper S to my old '84 Fiat X1/9. It's like having super glue tires going around corners!
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“I had a boxster before my Mini Cooper S, and I thought...”
Written on: 23/08/2005 by mrockrat (1 review written)
I had a boxster before my Mini Cooper S, and I thought that handled well. For sheer grin factor, my mini knocks spots off the porsche. Not as fast in a straight line, but in england we don't have many straight roads anyway. And I can leave it in the car park without having to worry about someone keying it. (read more)
★★★★☆
“I am writing this review of my Mini Cooper S 163bhp...”
Written on: 19/08/2005 by gingerbap
I am writing this review of my Mini Cooper S 163bhp (2002) having a good platform of comparison. An Audi Quattro, Mk1 VW Golf GTI, 2 x BMW 325i sports, Subaru WRX, BMW E34 M5 and Corrado VR6 are some of the cars I have owned in the previous 5 years.
I bought the Mini Cooper S some 4 months ago and have mixed feelings on my choice. The first thing that jumps up and quite literally smacks you in the face is the lack of performance... I am amazed to read other reviews online that continually...
(read more)
223916_Saakey's Response to 206942_gingerbap's Review
Written on: 06/01/2006
Expert? Should note...you bought a used 2002 model, The gearing they used back then was bad - It got off the line slow, etc... it's fixed in the newer models...
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“We just bought our used Mini Cooper S and have been...”
Written on: 07/08/2005 by lbbuk (1 review written)
We just bought our used Mini Cooper S and have been very pleased with it, the performance is very good and will be even better when we get the works kit.
The handling is brilliant and the car just looks great.
The only downside is that there is not a lot of room in the back, but that's not realy a big problem for us anyway.
(read more)
★★★★★
“I have just puchased a secondhand Cooper S after...”
Written on: 06/07/2005 by chelsea1
I have just puchased a secondhand Cooper S after trading in my Audi TT against it. At first I was very worried I had done the wrong thing but one week down the line you can't get the smile off my face. This car delivers in all areas and BMW should be very proud of itself. They have created a modern classic. The performance is as good as my 180 TT and I am confident that it handles just as well if not better (takes me back to my kart racing days). My advice to anyone thinking about buying a... (read more)
See next 10 reviews
Showing 21 - 30 of 70 Reviews
★★★★☆
“IMHO the Mini Cooper S is the most fun I've had in a...”
Written on: 08/01/2005 by GoldenJoystick (1 review written)
IMHO the Mini Cooper S is the most fun I've had in a hot hatch since the R5 Turbo.
Very solid build, brisk accleration from 0-90, u can almost get 50mph out of 1st gear if you ask it nicely!
I did a lot of research before buying this car and was confused at the varying perfomance stats from mags/websites claiming 0-60's from 7.8-6.9.
The mini drivers manual states 7.4 seconds & i'd have to say I agree when comparing it to other cars i've had the pleasure of racing - ibiza cupra 2.0T, focus...
(read more)
Samm's Response to GoldenJoystick's Review
Written on: 15/01/2005
16's are definitley best- the MCS does lose a bit top end but thats because it's supercharged- connected directly to the crank, so what you gain at the bottom end- you lose at the top end although BBR are very good and can uprate the Supercharger with very good results. Still, if you are racing a modded 172/182 Cup you will need more power to beat it but a standard one you will beat with a 200+bhp MCS.
Reply to this comment
Jazzrs360's Response to GoldenJoystick's Review
Written on: 29/03/2005
Great review, the Cooper S is a truly good car. I am an owner of a Skoda Octavia vRS Turbo and so I am always on the lookout for potenetial rivals which I love to compare to mine. Now the Cooper S is perhaps a car you buy with your heart, not your quite your head: other rivals offer more space, refinement, even performance etc... Fine, you'll appreciate the handling of the S more so than my Octavia vRS, but while both of them are in standard form, the S's 163 bhp is just not as effective as my 180 bhp (Autocar mag tested the vRS as 0-60 mph in 6.7 seconds). And the vRS costs less brand new (no, I'm NOT boasting!). I've had many encounters with the S- and it is by no means an easy advesary, in fact it is a highly surprising and dangerous one, but I have emerged victorious each and every time on the motorway. In the city however, I bow down to the Mini's agility and nippy characteristics. When you do your conversion however to get it up to 220 bhp or so, I expect that it will become a true super pocket rocket. 6 seconds 0-60 mph is easily reachable and provided your gears are fettled with, your S should be capable of a potential 150 mph give or take a few mph. Couple that to the Mini's small body and then you will have an allround killer. After that, your little Mini will be practically unstoppable, no doubt you already know that...I'm now cursing under my breath with envy! Good luck with it and happy motoring. :)
Reply to this comment
London2005's Response to GoldenJoystick's Review
Written on: 05/07/2005
bbr are fantasic, i had a passenger ride in their top spec demo car, 260+ bhp if i remember..absolutely fantastic!
Reply to this comment
★★★☆☆
“Having craved for a Mini Cooper S since it's launch, I...”
Written on: 24/11/2004 by leemondo (1 review written)
Having craved for a Mini Cooper S since it's launch, I finally took the plunge 3 months ago and bought a Mini Cherished Cooper S from a Mini Dealer.
The past 3 months have been the worst case of car ownership I have ever experienced. Poor cabin build quality with sqeaks and rattles, oil leak from the supercharger, humming noise at 60mph that Mini can't seem to repair under the warranty, smear marks on the passenger and driver door windows and all the Mini dealer can do is remark that 'they...
(read more)
Samm's Response to leemondo's Review
Written on: 02/01/2005
Have you tried a Leon 225 or CTR? Very quick and well made hot hatches.
Reply to this comment
Terri Lucrisia's Response to leemondo's Review
Written on: 27/01/2005
Wow! this is disapointing for someone interested in buying one. Did you purchase new, or used>
Reply to this comment
A2Antoni's Response to leemondo's Review
Written on: 19/07/2006
I agree, had one for 14 months and am ready to leave it by the side of the highway with the keys in it.
I have humming noises too, at 60 M/PH, mine is a 2005 model, had dash ripped out and foam put it to silence the squeaks, steering vibrations no matter how many times you rotate and balance wheels, engine mount replaced (engine was too rough and sending knocking vibrations throughout car), fixed now. Had front right headlight replaced due to faulty stamp of moulding (was sticking out), steering is predictable but very rough going over bumps. My suspension started to squeak and the air condition compressor shakes the entire car including my seat, feels like a bed in cheap motel that has coin operated vibration option. To sum it up, this car is the worst car I have ever owned, and yet to have an enjoyable moment with it, but locked into a lease for another 24 months. I use the car to get to work. The longest trip was 2 hrs tops. I would never risk my life in this car on a 5 hr trip to some other city.
<br/>
<br/>Anthony
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“I'm a car nut and when the new Mini Cooper S first...”
Written on: 31/07/2004 by artemc
I'm a car nut and when the new Mini Cooper S first came out I didn't really like it, but now some 3 years later I own a Mini S. A couple of changes added a lot to the performance, first the Magna Flow exhaust and then the smaller pulley. For me thats about it as I don't want to have to purchase stock in a tire company. The results are great, highly recommend both additions, only have to be careful of the local enforcement guys. (read more)
Ammorris's Response to 164415_artemc's Review
Written on: 03/09/2004
You might be able to help me then. I'm currently awaiting a Cooper S convertible. Delivery is due in October 2004. My husband has ordered it for me with various extras but I haven't even driven one! What can I expect?
Reply to this comment
172424_Rokguy5's Response to 164415_artemc's Review
Written on: 30/09/2004
You can expect to be suprised at how the car handles. I am also waiting on my cooper S. I will handle curves and corners like no other car. The handling of the car is better than the subaru WRX.
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“Well I am a 3 day expert ;) ”
Written on: 25/07/2004 by fitz70 (1 review written)
Well I am a 3 day expert ;)
I was lucky enough to get a ex-demo model Mini Cooper S which meant that the car was kitted out with HK Stereo, Xenons, Climate control, Aero kit, JCW kit and bonnet stripes (I got the Union Jack flag removed as being an Aussie I just couldn't live with myself!!).
All this for $14K below the list price. As I said the worst thing about the Mini is the cost. However it can also mean that a car now like mine is a bit of a rarity. The resale value (when and if I do...
(read more)
★★★★★
“I have had my Mini Cooper S for 1 month now and was...”
Written on: 03/05/2004 by nig6 (1 review written)
I have had my Mini Cooper S for 1 month now and was amazed by its acceleration and handling
Yes its heavy on fuel, but there again I had a 1.2 corsa before so its not really a fair comparison.
The main thing that impressed me with the mini is the build quality is amazing I suppose thats the BMW influence.
Yes its expensive, mine was £17k with chilli pack etc. but currently their holding their value so well and the new waiting lists are very long so they are still quite in demand
(read more)
Fionamail5's Response to nig6's Review
Written on: 08/07/2004
Am I the only one having trouble with reverse gear? Often trying many times before it will engage.
<br>
<br>I've been informed by the garage that this is a design flaw, and a new gearbox would have the same problem. Would be very interested to hear other comments.
Reply to this comment
Grabber's Response to nig6's Review
Written on: 24/05/2005
I've had my Mini Cooper S for well over a year and never had any trouble shifting into reverse.
Graham
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“If anyone is willing to spend money on getting the...”
Written on: 30/04/2004 by tommy224
If anyone is willing to spend money on getting the works tuning kit fitted to their Copper S, then they'll be willing to spend money on getting the West Tung kit fitted.
The west tuning kit costs around £5,500, I know that does sound a lot but you get 240 bhp 207 lb of torque.
0-60 time drops to under 6 seconds and top speed over 150 mph, if there is a kit to get this is it at the moment.
(read more)
Melred's Response to 152996_tommy224's Review
Written on: 01/06/2004
Is this kit available outside of the U.K ie Australia? I would be very interested in obtaining it. Thanks.
Reply to this comment
166452_Archiejughead's Response to 152996_tommy224's Review
Written on: 19/08/2004
This particular kit is known to cause damage.
Reply to this comment
★★★☆☆
“I am flabbergasted by the 18 slams on Mr. Oneill. ”
Written on: 05/03/2004 by Shooter 1000 (1 review written)
I am flabbergasted by the 18 slams on Mr. Oneill.
I don't own the Mini Cooper S due to my extended test drive of one and of the of various alternatives some with much more enthsiast appeal and the feeling that the S fell far short of what it could have offered the enthusiast. Cars are a big investment. Time should be spent testing as many alternatives as possible to be able to make a really informed purchase. Reading auto magazines will not help if they are receiving huge advertising...
(read more)
Samm's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 06/03/2004
Having tuned old mini's I think the main problem with the new Minicooper S is that it is a BMW. The old minis were so much fun to drive and one of the best cars to learn about handling, I had them sideways on a number of occasions. BMW's are refined heavy and well built, they are not usually associated with fun driving, other than the m3. So when you combine the two there are some contradictions that don't fit well.
<br>I have to agree-why did they not put a turbo on the car instead and did they really think 163bhp would be enough in light of the forthcoming 200bhp Civic, 206 180 and now 182 clio?
<br>I haven't driven the MCS but I have driven the Civic and it is mental, i'm absolutley convinved that there is no way the MCS will keep up with this car (or the clio cup) on any road.
<br>So now there are various tuning kits available (works) but they cost 2-3k, so if you want a really good mini you have to pay £18,000 which is also the same price as the 225bhp Leon Cupra r which will also trounce the mini.
<br>I think the mini looks great although perhaps it should be called a maxi cos lets face it it isnt very small anymore-my 205 1.9 is a much smaller car. Well I hear there is a second incarnation on it's way with improvements but the mk2 civic type r is already out and it's even more fantastic than the 1st one(which recently beat an s2000 round a track) and the clio 182 is recieving rave reviews as well. Watch this space??
Reply to this comment
146762_H4Yabusa's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 08/03/2004
the mini cooper s will easily keep up if not surpass a civic type R, ive recently test drove the type R, mini cooper s, clio cup & leon cupra r.
<br>
<br>the clio cup feels the best on the road out of the lot but the lack of features and comfort turned me off the car, the mini cooper s was a close second behind the cup but offered more creature comforts, then followed the civic type R & then the leon cupra R.
<br>
<br>seems everyone compares top end BHP & 0-60 times but thats not the point, the civic is quick but drivability is not so good same as the leon, with the civic you need to thrash the engine around 4000rpm before the cam profile changes & the car starts to move & the 225bhp in the leon is nothing special, its a larger car than the mini so the power/weight ratio is only slightly better.
<br>
<br>the civic is a normally aspirated engine that gives a turbo feel, and the leon is a turbo so they do feel faster in a straight line, but come to corners & the clio cup & mini feel much more solid & composed, and because there's no need to thrash the engine, exit speed from corners is alot better.
<br>
<br>so after driving them all i chose to get a mini cooper s, and with the 220bhp conversion by BBR or hartge then the leon & type R are left behind.
Reply to this comment
Samm's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 17/03/2004
I have to say- i think my favourite is the clio cup- for 13k it is brilliant and if you just spend 2k on it (the same as a standard mcs) you will have 220bhp no problems, but I have read a number of reviews and the Civic Type R always beat the rest around a track including an s2000!
<br>Basically it comes down to you'r driving style.
<br>I havent driven the Leon but know that 270+ bhp can easily be had with just a chip, exhaust and air filter, and I find it hard to believe that even a 220bhp mini would beat it.
<br>Personally I will keep my 185 bhp 205 mi16= approx 203 bhp per tonne for now although I am tempted to do a little project with a Clio cup or get a 6 speed ibiza tdi up to 200brake and 300 pounds of torque.
<br>.It's a shame they don't make cars like the 205 anymore, that are a real handful and take a really skillful drive. I drove a modern Impreza and it was so well set up that even at really fast speeds it just feels too easy to drive. a 220 bhp mcs will have about 176 bhp per tonne. I think this will cost a similar amount to a 250bhp Focus rs or even a standard Impreza.
Reply to this comment
Adamlondon69's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 20/08/2004
Unfortunately there is one rather important factor that you seemed to have missed in your otherwise comprehensive review, which is insurance. I’m 23 and can just afford the £1,500 per year that my Cooper S costs me in insurance. I couldn’t afford to insure a Civic Type R, let alone an Evo or WRX, and I can’t modify the car either. From this standpoint the Cooper S is rather good value. For a young driver such as my self the Cooper S is one of the best cars in its (insurance) class. As for a MX5, my girlfriend has one, and you couldn’t pay me to own one...
Reply to this comment
Hobzy's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 23/08/2004
To drive the same as the M3, surely it would need rear wheel drive? A minor point i thought...
<br>
<br>Its only a 1.6 - a supercharger gives a much better torque spread than a Turbo in such a small engine. This allows you to feather the revs around corners throughout the range giving ample chance of good speed through the corner - getting the back end out is not the quickest way round a track.
<br>
<br>For it to be as track ready as a civic type r, but with the same solid BMW feel, interior etc, the price would be ridiculous - the mini in both incarnations (and ive had both) is subscribing to about a certain style of car - and not everyone tracks them like you or i do.
<br>
<br>The S has never been marketed like the Type r, RS etc, so why do people keep expecting it to outshine them?
<br>
<br>(although my MCS JCW did stuff a civic type r the other day at the track :D ;) )
Reply to this comment
167864_Peterb05Mini's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 30/08/2004
Seems like comparisons are being made which should not be made. Seems like someone is mad at BMW, superchargers, and other things. We are getting history lessons on technical aspects which 'really do not matter, or are not relevant'.
Reply to this comment
Samm's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 29/09/2004
true, the mini has very different charecteristics to an m3, but regardless of the fact that it is not rwd or naturally aspirated it is still the closest to any other bmw to drive. Despite mx5's having a bit of a girlie image, they are still one of the most fun cars I have driven, the handling and gearchange are just superb.
Reply to this comment
Exciteable's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 27/01/2005
Sounds like you guys would enjoy the good old MK1 MR2s. Even the standard NAs are great but check out the imported 1.6 supercharged models which can be tuned to 180-190 bhp, which from a rear wheel drive ~900kg car is awesome! The only down side is that there are two small boots instead of one not so small boot.
<br>At a couple of thousand pounds for a mint example I think you'd agree there is no competition!
Reply to this comment
Samm's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 28/01/2005
Certainly a very good car but Touring s14's are coming in cheap these days and is a far superior car to even the legendary MK1 MR2 S. MCS has a 6 speed box and still only 135 top end because the Supercharger is connected directly to the crank shaft, you lose in top end what you gain at bottom end. The MCS is compared to these cars because it is a hot hatch and is in the same price bracket, marketing doesn't even come into it IMO. And no not even a clio cup or MCS will out handle a CTR.
Reply to this comment
Exciteable's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 02/02/2005
Samm wrote: "Certainly a very good car but Touring s14's are coming in cheap these days and is a far superior car to even the legendary MK1 MR2"
<br>
<br>Excuse my ignorance but what's a Touring s14?
Reply to this comment
Samm's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 02/02/2005
Not at all, it is a Nissan 200 S14 (S13 was around 86-93) the Touring model (98on) has "evil" headlights, leather interior and a few other goodies. It uses the legendary nissan Pulsar engine but in a detuned state and it is ridiculously easy to tune.
Reply to this comment
Exciteable's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 04/02/2005
IMO a tuned Nissan 200 is a rocket ship, agreed, but not a pocket rocket like the cars discussed here. The combined boot space of a Mk1 Mr2 is not far off that of a prelude and I would guess an S14. But the handling or 'chuckability' factor would leave the little old MR2 near the top of the pile with the "touring car" Nissan at the bottom. As you can probably guess (by my possible bias) I own a classic MR2 and can even get a couple of seven foot surfboards on the roof rack! :)
Reply to this comment
Gavin1978's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 20/06/2005
Got to the 3rd paragraph and got bored. Is it not a little difficult to rate a car after having just a week test drive??
Reply to this comment
202844_Davenia7's Response to Shooter 1000's Review
Written on: 21/07/2005
Ok, so maybe it's because I'm a girl, but does anyone care that the Mini Cooper S is cute. I mean I know about cars a great deal and have test driven the alternatives, but honestly, the Mini was the car that made the most sense. Perhaps, it is bc I drive 50 miles a day, living in Atl, GA, but that car is sooooo darn cute and if you never have an opportunity to get the car over 20 mph due to traffic, then who cares about fast. Still, it is nice to have enough power to get out of the way of semis and crazy SUV drivers that feel they are the owners of the road. So, my next purchase will either be the Mini bc it's cute, or the Prius bc it's hybrid.
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“As an Automotive Engineer who previously worked at...”
Written on: 01/03/2004 by wobert (1 review written)
As an Automotive Engineer who previously worked at Lotus, I'm probably in a better position to qualify how the MINI handles relative to other cars available.
The finest front wheel drive car ever produced was the FWD Lotus Elan ('89-'95). The MCS is probably the closest direct rival to that car, in terms of entertainment, safety of road-holding, grip and pure chuckability.
To get a more responsive car, you would need to go to a mid engined vehicle, but you would then lose out in terms of...
(read more)
Samm's Response to wobert's Review
Written on: 04/03/2004
I really like this car although I think a lot of people buy it just to pose and not because they really like cars.
<br>BMW mini might have lost a bit of it's driver enjoyment factor?
<br>Having driven the CTR I was really impressed with this car and I think the only way I would prefer a MCS over a CTR would be if it was modified. I am also very interested in the Clio Cup and given that it is so much cheaper than it's rivals, anyone driven one?
<br>Also - do you think a MCS has better handling than an Integra type r? if so it must be amazingly good.
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“I absolutly adore my Mini Cooper S, it is without a...”
Written on: 20/02/2004 by lcmorris (1 review written)
I absolutly adore my Mini Cooper S, it is without a doubt the most fun car on the road. Its nippy and quick and it always attracts attention from other drivers, passers by and fellow mini owners. You can make it your own with various extras and colour combinations, which is good for those who like to be individual. Apart from its few trips to the garage it hasnt been problematic at all. Fab car, I would recommend it to anyone!! (read more)
★★★★★
“Mini Cooper S: I've never really owned a car that was...”
Written on: 07/02/2004 by kraaylandis (1 review written)
Mini Cooper S:
I've never really owned a car that was worth dedicating words to;
but growing up on the lesser side of a wealthy family, and being a risk taker,
could not resist sneaking one of my uncles babies out when not a creature
was stirring. Mercedes, Porsche, Ferrari; if but only for 3 hours at a time,
I have tasted ..driving joy.
My personal string of mundane machines never touched me like uncle's
toys. Then I bought a MCS. Now, I won't kid you, and exotic it is not,
I can...
(read more)
See next 10 reviews
Showing 31 - 40 of 70 Reviews
★★☆☆☆
“In low gears the Mini Cooper S is embarrisingly slow...”
Written on: 02/02/2004 by martinoneill (4 reviews written)
In low gears the Mini Cooper S is embarrisingly slow off the mark. Not what you after splashing out the cash. It is like the fuel supply is limited until the revs reach about 3500. Then it's woosh
Also the handling is poor for a racer - far too spongey and unresponsive.
I hated it and sold mine......
(read more)
Adamlondon69's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 05/02/2004
Putting reliability over performance? The car is faster than 90% of hatchbacks, but if you were looking for a performance car then you would have been better suited to buy a Porsche. Also, whilst I love my Mini Cooper S I know that they have some reliability problems (a factor which you are obviously not aware of). Spongy suspension? The Cooper S comes with sports plus suspension as standard, and if you get the Chilli pack it also comes with 17\" alloys with runflat tyres. These both give the car a stiff ride, and I have taken very tight corners at speed and am yet to feel any real body roll. If the car can be given so much acclaim and praise from organisations and motoring journalists all over the world, and yet you write such a review, then someone is wrong, and you are somewhat out numbered. All the same, I hope you are happier with your new car.
Reply to this comment
Jim Voyles's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 13/02/2004
If you had a MINI-Cooper S, you just don\'t know what to expect from your car. I once talked to a guy with a SAAB 9-3 who told me it was a lousy winter car. I owned one at the time, and it came with 55 series performance tires (Michelin Pilots). He seemed to be under the impression that he could drive it in deep snow with those tires! Are you that kind of car owner (I hesitate to use the word driver)?
Reply to this comment
Martinoneill's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 17/02/2004
Well what can I say - spot the BMW staff using the site!
Reply to this comment
Tabate's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 19/02/2004
I\'m sure you you are only expressing your opinion about your own personal experiences. I\'m only curious about a few things that you have written ....
<br>
<br>1. No torque, well I\'ve driven a lot of cars and having said that. Whatever made you think a car with 1600 CC and 8.5:1 compression was going to have any torque? The supercharger does add some bottom end but if you were expecting Rat motor style torque you were dreaming. These cars love to be spun, the tighter the better. I suppose you might have been disgruntalled driving a 69\' Z/28 as well they had about the same driving style requirement.
<br>
<br>2. The soft handling? What is your daily driver a skateboard?. Admittedly
<br>these cars are not for everyone and you must be one of the those people.
<br>
<br>I hope the person you sold your mini to knows how to drive it and I hope you enjoy your Honda Accord.
Reply to this comment
Olio's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 24/02/2004
Perhaps you should volunteer to help BMW develop the next one. With someone of your experience on their team it's bound to be a \much greater success than the critically hammered current Cooper S.
Reply to this comment
Martinoneill's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 24/02/2004
Thanks for the comments:
<br>
<br>I know how to drive, probably more than you and I certainly don\'t own a Honda.
Reply to this comment
Tabate's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 24/02/2004
The funny thing about this entire conversation is that neither of you really care about the Mini at all. The simple statement of the facts is you both hate BMW with a passion that rivals the Hatfields and Mccoy's.
<br>
<br>Just to let you both know, yes I have ownwed many BMW's over the years as well as M-Benz, Chevrolets, Fords, Dodges and many other brands. Do I think this makes me a BMW RavBoy ... nope. I do enjoy driving them but not as much as the I currently enjoy the Mini.
<br>
<br>I am sorry you didn't like your Mini but as I stated before they are not for everyone. To your fellow poster ... I hope you only buy things writers and reviews say you can. To bad you didn't listen to their wisdom a few years ago and not wasted your money on the PC you wrote your reply on.
<br>
<br>P.S> Sorry about the Accord crack .. I meant to say Civic
Reply to this comment
Martinoneill's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 24/02/2004
Who says a mini cooper s is slow:
<br>
<br>Official Figures:
<br>1.6L Mini Cooper S 0-62 7.7 Seconds
<br>1 Litre Diahatsu Charade GTi 0-62 7.9 Seconds.
<br>
<br>So you can't even beat obscure 1 litre cars from the lights.
<br>
<br>The Cooper is slow - it's offical.
Reply to this comment
Adamlondon69's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 25/02/2004
OFFICIAL: Mini Cooper S 0-60 7.4 secs.
<br>
<br>I dont know how fast a car you think you can buy for £14,600? If you are talking on the grand scheme of things, then 7.4 is slow compared to a Porsche, SL 55 AMG, Dodge Viper etc... If you are talking about the area of the market that the Mini is in (ie sub £20,000 hot-hatch) then it is one of the fastest. Its all relative. There are not many cars that are awarded 5 stars in Top Gear, but this is one of them. And I dont work for BMW, Im just a very satisfied customer.
<br>
<br>PS:
<br>BMW X4, 4.4i V8, 286 bhp, 0-60 7.5 secs...
<br>BMW 735i, 272 bhp, 0-60 7.5 secs...
<br>AUDI A4, 3.0 V6 Sport, 217 bhp, 0-60 7.8 secs...
<br>
<br>Mini Cooper S, 1.6, 163 bhp, 0-60 7.4 secs
Reply to this comment
Martinoneill's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 25/02/2004
Well if you believe without question the awards of Top Gear then you are the perfect Mini Cooper S owner. Enjoy
<br>
<br>If you have a brain and can see through the hype - buy something else, or at least be a bit wary.
<br>
<br>If someone reading this is actually thinking of getting one, organise a test drive and see for yourself.
<br>
<br>The drive is not great but maybe you'll be like most people on this site and be satisfied with the looks alone.
Reply to this comment
Olio's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 25/02/2004
I'd just like to point out to anyone who missed it - I was being sarcastic. I think the mini is great, and can't wait for mine to be delivered in April. I've driven all manner of cars myself, and although I'm not a big fan of BMW (particularly image-wise)I think the Mini is one of the most entertaining cars I've ever driven in any price bracket.
Reply to this comment
Karjon's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 26/02/2004
I agree with you martin although the cooper S is not slow (relatively of course), Most mini owners love the look and have been deluded by the marketing which has convinced them it handles great, I\'m not saying its got bad handling but its handling has come from new developments in shock absorbers and tyres rather than from inherent good design. I recently took my Cooper S to a favourite windy bit of road and although it wasn\'t terrible I was expecting a lot more, my friend brought a 1983 Alfasud ti (105 bhp) which was standard e.g. no aftermarket suspension and had it had a few more horsepower (or god forbid a supercharger) it would have eaten the mini alive. I think people go to much into bodyroll, instead take note of what enter/exit speeds of a corner are and how the car accelerates as it turns out. I would expect very little bodyroll in a 2003 car with new stiff suspension.
<br>
<br>K. (15 yrs rally exp.)
Reply to this comment
Adamlondon69's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 27/02/2004
Yes, that’s right Martin, I spent £18,000 on a car because Top Gear said so! In fact there was actually rather a lot of research that went into the car I chose to buy, and a lot of other people have come to the same conclusion. There are few if any other cars that generate the same cult following that the new Mini has, and this is not because of the say so of a car magazine such as Top Gear. It is quite clear from the other people that have commented on your review (and other reviews here) that your opinions are not shared by the general public. I still don’t understand what you were expecting to buy for the money, because in its class the Cooper S is at the head of the pack. If you have no further interest in this car (as appears so) then why not simply stop commenting on the subject and focus on giving great reviews on the car that you chose to replace your Mini with (which I’m sure we would be very interested in knowing). The fact that you think that everyone who has given positive reviews of the Cooper S works for BMW just goes to show the true depth of your ignorance.
Reply to this comment
Martinoneill's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 28/02/2004
That\'s exactly the point - I am glad another experienced driver uses this site.
<br>
<br>It is not about the Mini Cooper S being a poor car - reliability issues aside - more that it fails to be as good as it should be. If it was a poser purchase you will be entirely satisfied.
Reply to this comment
Downpit's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 01/03/2004
MY MINI COOPER S IS FALLING TO BITS
<br>
<br>I live in sydney but am English, couldnt wait for the car to get delivered. just like to say that whilst the car is great fun to drive, im over it being in the garage. 4 times with only 2,500 miles on the clock, 10 months old and its a death trap, steering has gone, supercharger unit dodgy, electrics gone and the interior has been a disaster. paint peeling off the steering wheel, inside door handles and the silver supports around the stereo etc. Hate to say it, I love the cars drive but with so many problems I hate to think what will realy HAPPEN when I do some serious milage.
<br>
<br>Also other things that have been replaced are the 2 front seats, leather stitching went on one anf the mechanism went on passenger, boot lock replaced, handbrake surround came away and the breaks have been re done.
Reply to this comment
Buttons's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 01/03/2004
The Cooper S is one of the most fun cars around, oh yeah and the handling is so useless that I completely toasted a TT in mine round a series of roundabouts over the weekend! ;)
Reply to this comment
Bacardi's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 01/03/2004
Well get this, im not a part of BMW, infact I dislike much of there range, but the mini stands out as a great little car. The reason why its so appealing, isnt about 0-60 times, not its track times etc etc, but about FUN. I acually dont care how fast im going, so long as its fun. Take karting, its way slower than many cars, but boy is it fun. Handling may not be fit for a true race, but its a road car and has to be right in all situations. The steering is Direct and possitive, grip is well balanced and progressive. how you can say its spongy is beyond me (ooohhhh your used to driving steam engines maybe?)
<br>My Advice, forget times and figures, take it for a drive, and all of a sudden you wont care about that cos your having the best time of your life.
<br>
<br>So what car have you got now?
Reply to this comment
145754_Planeguy's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 01/03/2004
A. The average rating by category of the review does not accurately reflect in the overall rating. The overall rating should be about 3.5 stars, which clearly show that this guy has an agenda.
<br>
<br>B. I agree that this guy has very little knowlege. "no torque under 3500" This is a small displacement high-rev engine, I guess if he drove and S2000 or acura nsx he would have the same complaint. It is a basic understanding of how to drive and how horsepower is developed and delivered that bugs me.
<br>
<br>C. by the latest NADA report the cooper retains 117% of its original value after 1year and he ranks 5/10 for value, agian a clear bias
<br>http://www.mini2.com/news/news.php?id=160
<br>
<br> I have a feeling that this guy likes american muscle cars, drives a camaro in primer and is upset that he can't handle any curves
Reply to this comment
145756_Worksgirl's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 01/03/2004
See through the 'hype'??.. I wasn't aware that they had to hype up Minis. They speak for themselves... and the S speaks the loudest. A decent driver would never call it slow off the mark.
<br>"Also the handling is poor for a racer - far too spongey and unresponsive." I'm sorry but this is blatantly untrue. I raced around Goodwood and ate race ready M3s for breakfast. The car is awesome.
Reply to this comment
Stevedrivesamcs's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 01/03/2004
I\'d like to make a couple of comments on this review. I recently took ownership of a Mini Cooper S after driving a many number of cars in order to choose the one which was the most fun and practical to drive. The MCS handles extremly well. It has very little roll and the combination of torque, delivery and handling means although the rise is a little firm the car is quicker from point to point over anything this side of a 996 GT2/3. Although it could benefit from a little more bhp, the overall effectiveness of this car as a fun/ b-road car is excellent. As for BMW, I used to work for them and didn\'t particuarly like the company or cars, most of them not being what I\'d prefer to drive (with the exception of the E36 M3) but against those feelings I still purchased an MCS. It\'s a great buy and a fantastic car. While I respect your opinions I would disagree with your original review.
Reply to this comment
Karjon's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 02/03/2004
Ive got a honda accord.... I took your advice and \"just took it for a test drive\" wow i didn\'t care that I was only going 15kph round a corner because \"it was so much fun\". Take the point, I\'m not saying the mini is terrible or even bad, but when mine arrived I had been led to believe it was gonna be fantastic and it wasn\'t. I prefered my old Fiat Uno T. The cooper S has been made out to be a true drivers car, which it isn\'t. Car now? gave the cooper to my wife, bought the sud off my mate, till I find something newer. Any suggestions?
Reply to this comment
Jim Voyles's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 02/03/2004
Mr. O’Neill, I have the right to disagree with your review of the car, before I bought my MINI I had never owned any BMW product. (I’m also a motorcyclist, favoring Honda products.) Opinions are opinions, especially where cars are concerned, but your comments on the MINI’s handling totally negate the rest of your review.
Reply to this comment
Vector625's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 02/03/2004
Let\'s talk performance. My stock \'04 MCS was clocked at 6.87 seconds 0-60mph here at the track in New Jersey. Temperature was 36F. Maybe you\'re a large person or something.
<br>
<br>If you think the handling is spongy, then yours was a dud. Let\'s put aside the figures from Car & Driver and Road & Track that put the MINI above all other cars in slalom performance. Let\'s talk about real world experience. What are you basing your claims on? My experience on twisty river roads, traffic circles, and the one timed slalom were spectacular.
<br>-vector625
Reply to this comment
Hobzy's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 03/03/2004
Hmm, just checked the MINI official website to see where it harps on about it being a 'true drivers car'. Couldnt find it. what it does go on about for the whole range is how the design makes it easy to drive in a more fun way ie quicker. In this respect it does EXACTLY what it says on the tin. Not everyone wants the back end out like Tiff Needel. Most want a predictable car that "feels" fast. Ive driven all sorts including some alfas and some of them were great drives. But none felt as surefooted as my S Works. And as for torque it has been said before, Minis old and new were meant to be revved.
Reply to this comment
Samm's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 04/03/2004
I think the mini is a fantastic car and I haven\'t driven it but against the competition I think it would have to be a clio cup or CTR. Having driven the CTR I find it hard to believe that a mini is more fun or can keep up with this car on any road it really is good. Being a 205 1.9 driver with some subtle mods I doubt the mini is as entertaining to drive or is more of a handful, probably because it is some 15 years more modern and weighs around 300-350kgs more which is a hell of a lot. I have also driven a Fiat Uno turbo 160bhp in a 900kg car and it was a riot! But the MCS works addition looks very addition if you can afford it- it\'s entering Focus RS territory with the price. Anyone driven these cars??
Reply to this comment
Coopersworks's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 10/03/2004
I have a Mini Cooper S Works and I sold my Lotus Elise (series 2) for it.
<br>
<br>The Mini outhandles, out-guns and out shines the Lotus on the public roads. On the track though, the Lotus would be faster!
<br>
<br>My car has a few mods - lowered springs, induction, manifold, sports cat - Recent dyno saw it at just a touch over 220bhp.
<br>
<br>...and I didn't buy it because of the "hype". I bought it as I'm interested in good handling, fun cars!
Reply to this comment
Samm's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 17/03/2004
Sounds cool!, I love the look of the mini even if it is a bit chunky and heavy, but for the price of a 220 bhp works I just think that the rivals might out gun it.
<br>For 19k you can easily get a 275 bhp Leon Cupra R or
<br>16k the new Civic which will do 0-60 in 6.6 and you have all that money left over to sup it up and even the MK1 beat an S2000!
<br>Or for 15k you can get a Clio Cup up to the same power, and it weighs about over 250kgs less so will be faster and cheaper.
<br>Or you can probaly get a 250+bhp focus rs for 21k.
<br>I really like the MCS but there are too many people that drive it cos they think they are trendy but it just makes it less exclusive.
Reply to this comment
Spinaltap19's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 28/03/2004
I have had my MINI Cooper S for just over 12 months and have been absolutely delighted with it. Whilst it would definitely benefit from another 40 bhp, the car manages to be amazingly civilised when driven gently and a total hoot when pedal pressed to metal. My friends new Honda Civic Type R is faster but far noisier and less relaxing to drive and, of course, lacks that MINI class, history, race pedigree and sense of style. How many cars can truly upstage all of the actors in a film including the oscar-winning Charlize Theron? I raced a Cooper S (unmodified) around Croft race circuit last Summer and it was amazing: totally forgiving of any mid-corner excess, bucket loads of grip and plenty of grins from ear-to-ear. Did I mention the residuals? I'm sure Martin O'Neill got a very nice trade-in price for his MINI which will have surely given him something to smile about as he waved it good bye!
Reply to this comment
151097_Chris001's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 11/04/2004
I have owned my Cooper s for 12 months now and I am delighted with it. I have had better looking meatier cars but my mini is my favourite by far. It corners fantastic. It can safely overtake just about anything on a country road and in another 2 years when I swap it in I expect ill get a really good trade in on it. I didn't buy the car because I wanted a santa pod dragster I bought it because it was nippy, fairly priced, and 3 years of trouble free motoring and so far its not let me down once. This car is everything it claims to be and more.
Reply to this comment
159674_Johnscudder's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 22/06/2004
Hello...
<br>Well, I'm not a drag racer nor an expert on off-road type racing. I have owned Firebirds, Trans Ams, Miata's, Thunderbirds, Cadilliac's... all over the "range" of vehicles. The funnist car I've driven is the Miata. Once person said, "It goes where you point it"... which has proved true. I test road (multiple times.. almost to the irritation of the dealer!) the Mini S. I gotta admit, it's a unique car... and in great contract to my current F250 supercab diesel superduty! (grin). I'm a car person. What I did find in my driving the Mini S is that it is fun, but a bit uncomfortable on the seating... where the seating is a bit "trandelenberb" (pointed down towards the gluteous maximus) unless you crank it up a bit in height. The test vehicle I drove (over and over) had many rattles, and the last time I drove it the car pulled heavily to the right... something that the dealer also seemed surprised to find. I had just driven it 2 days prior. I first noted a bit of a rattle in the passenger door at the window, and the last time out, there seemed to be many rattles when going over a semi-bumpy road. I've also been test driving the Imprenza... spelling? It's the Subaru WRX.. with 227 HP and all wheel drive. It's about 27k compared to the 32k cooper S (they are marking up the vehicles here in the San Diego area). I've also tested the WRX STI... which has 300 HP and drives like a rocket.. and corners like my mother-in-law avoiding a family gathering (just kidding). Anyway, like I said, I'm a "car" person, and not a specialist. By trade, I'm an RN in the ER and ICU... but by night (and sometimes day)... I love to drive.. drive drive drive. With all I've heard about the mechanical tid bits that tend to eventually go wrong with the Mini's paint and other oddities, I wonder whether I'll be using that 4 year 50,000k warrenty a lot. Just my two cents. I saw a Toyota MR2 in the showroom the other day.. I'll be giving that a ride. It was only 26k on the sticker.. no mark up. Take care... John
Reply to this comment
Mac13's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 18/07/2004
Take a drive and see for your self. I was not convinced about the car until I had a good drive and now have one on order. Forget reading about it drive it.
Reply to this comment
Fitz70's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 25/07/2004
I have currently just switched from a V8 5.7L 230kW Commodore to a Cooper S Works. They both spec the same 0-100 figure so I TOTALLY disagree that the Mini is slow.
<br>
<br>I have only owned mine for 3 days yet the driving techniques used to get a Mini off the mark compared to a V8 are obviously very different. The V8 has a huge amount of torque and so putting the foot to the floor the thing responds in almost any gear. That said using a good amount of revs and getting the correct gear and the Mini goes like the clappers and handles like it's on rails (something a rear wheel drive V8 just CANNOT do!).
<br>
<br>I just can't seem to work out what car Martin was driving....
Reply to this comment
Bill 42's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 03/08/2004
I haven't bought a Mini S yet, but I will as soon as I sell my Harley. After test driving one, it would have taken an undertaker to wipe the smile off of my face. Unlike my bike, I wouldn't get wet, cold, or hot while still being able to carry someone else plus luggage. Being a senior citizen and having sold and driven many cars, it was the most fun I've ever had behind a steering wheel. A 911 it isn't, but for me, it's the next best thing that is affordable. It's just putting fun back into getting from here to there and grinning the whole time.
Reply to this comment
Martinoneill's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 29/09/2006
I have spoken to many Cooper S owners now that have also found the driving experience a let down. For example, compared with other (cheaper) FWD hatches it lags behind vehicles like the Integra Type R and even the Clio Cup.
<br/>
<br/>As such, for a car billed as a drivers car it is below average for the money.
<br/>
<br/>I can understand so many people rising to defend the car - if I had just bought one and did not have much experience of other "hot" FWD cars I would do the same.
Reply to this comment
Spinaltap19's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 30/09/2006
I think Martin wants a car that really feels fast to satisfy his boy racer urges.
<br/>
<br/>For me, having just stepped out of my MINI Cooper S, the best thing is that the car just drives effortlessly and doesn't feel particularly fast as you are going along. There is no drama, no tyre squealing, no high revving hysterics, just a good drive in a car that feels in the millionaire class - Madonna seems pretty happy with hers. Around a race track, I am sure that the MINI Cooper GP works, with no rear seats it is very much the business, but driving (fairly) legally on normal roads, in a safe yet fun fashion, the Cooper S is ideal.
<br/>
<br/>My only mistake was allowing my wife to drive it: I barely get a look in now, and I am relegated to driving the family MPV!
Reply to this comment
Adamlondon69's Response to martinoneill's Review
Written on: 02/10/2006
It’s been almost three years since I bought my Cooper S, and I’m still extremely happy with it. I’m having as much fun now with the car as when I bought it, and I would definitely recommend it to anyone who is in the market for a car of this kind. There has been a lot of banter on this review, either side of the fence, but the fact that the overwhelming majority of this has been on the positive side, just goes to prove that it is a great little car. And that’s just it; it’s a little car. People that are expecting a pure bred sports car are going to be disappointed, because it’s only a small hatchback. The fact is that it is a fun little car with more than enough voom for most, and it is well styled and hangs on to its value better than pretty much any car on sale in the UK today. If you would not consider buying one because of the foolish and unfounded negative statements that have been made on this page, then more fool you.
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“The Mini Cooper S is a sweet ride, supercharged which...”
Written on: 31/12/2003 by SpeedFreak19 (2 reviews written)
The Mini Cooper S is a sweet ride, supercharged which is very cool, has the capability to produce 200+ bhp, small with lots of power = very quick which is very sweet, aint too keep on the kit or one of the kits anyway. Nice set of big rims twin centre exit exhaust n roarin engine is all you need. A turbo would make the car so so much sweeter. (read more)
Adamlondon69's Response to SpeedFreak19's Review
Written on: 12/01/2004
A turbo-charger and a super-charger? Whoa! Is that even possible... I would recommend those of you with a need for more power to just have the John Cooper Works conversion, or perhaps the Hartge or Digitech conversion (although they will invalidate the warranty)
Reply to this comment
152996_Tommy224's Response to SpeedFreak19's Review
Written on: 25/04/2004
If you go for the works kit your warranty is still available however any other kit and the warranty then becomes void. You can't have a turbo and a supercharger in the same car, The supercharger however is the one i'd go for as you get no lag like a turbo and power increases can be huge.
Reply to this comment
163477_Turboman's Response to SpeedFreak19's Review
Written on: 24/07/2004
just test driven this little pocket rocket. Eats the road if uv got a heavy right foot. Like the 6th gear as well. Super sound from a great engine. Buy it!
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“I love the Mini Cooper S, no doubt about it. The suv...”
Written on: 25/12/2003 by pdivizzle0112 (2 reviews written)
I love the Mini Cooper S, no doubt about it. The suv backlash starts now baby (read more)
Gottahavamini's Response to pdivizzle0112's Review
Written on: 05/01/2004
It is my understanding that there is a governor that shuts the car down at 135 MPH.
Reply to this comment
Pdivizzle0112's Response to pdivizzle0112's Review
Written on: 06/01/2004
ABSOLUTELY NOT, MY JOHN COOPER WORKS MINI SAYS THAT THE TOP SPEED IS 140, AND IVE HIT 150 ON IT. 0-60 IN 6.3 SECONDS, MAY I ASK WHERE U HEARD THIS FROM?
Reply to this comment
Smadasam's Response to pdivizzle0112's Review
Written on: 23/03/2004
The regular Coopers there is a governor, but if you have the works package, the governor is removed.
Reply to this comment
★★★★☆
“The Mini Cooper S looks good, comfortable to drive,...”
Written on: 16/12/2003 by gordongreig (1 review written)
The Mini Cooper S looks good, comfortable to drive, nice interior,handles excellent. It could have been better. (read more)
★★★★★
“I,ve owned my Mini Cooper S for just over a year and...”
Written on: 13/12/2003 by nimini (1 review written)
I,ve owned my Mini Cooper S for just over a year and still can't get the smile off my face. Awesome in the twisties, all it does is keep on turning. A Go-Kart with A/C and a CD Player is how I describe my Mini Cooper "S" when asked what it's like. It is so much fun to drive that it should be illegal!!! From the day I test drove one until even today the Smile hasn't left my face. My old Drag Racing hand loves the gear shifter, and the car responds incredibly when the shifter is stirred just... (read more)
Falconcrest32's Response to nimini's Review
Written on: 22/01/2004
Is the oil filter accessable or is it hard to reach?
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“I have just ordered the Cooper S last wednesday, and...”
Written on: 11/12/2003 by adamlondon69 (2 reviews written)
I have just ordered the Cooper S last wednesday, and am counting the days till the dealership hand over the keys to my new car (about 6 weeks to go). The day before I took the Honda Civic Type R out for a test, and whilst the car was very fast, it had no character or charm. The mini is about half a second slower getting to 60, but for comfort, smooth gearchanges with a short 6 box, and efforless clutch, this is the better car. I've also opted for the Harman Kardon stero, which, if its... (read more)
Txboyracer's Response to adamlondon69's Review
Written on: 14/12/2003
You won't be disappointed. I took delivery of my '04 MINI S 10/25, 1 of the 1st, if not the 1st '04 in North Texas. I sold my '94 GMC P/U, which wasn't easy; but definitely glad I did now.
<br>Me BoyRacer is awesome.
Reply to this comment
Nads205's Response to adamlondon69's Review
Written on: 19/02/2004
You state that the mini is about half a second quicker to 60. You forget to mention that it's several seconds slower getting to 100 and far slower through the gears. Where the Civic will easily hit the motorway from a slip road at a ton+ comfortably, the mini would struggle.
Reply to this comment
Adamlondon69's Response to adamlondon69's Review
Written on: 19/02/2004
Er, no. On closer inspection you will actually see that I wrote that the Cooper S was about half a second SLOWER getting to 60. I am aware that the car is slower, but even though it is actually more fun to drive. And as for struggling to get to 100 mph... you obviously have not driven one properly. I have had the car for nearly a month now and it is plenty fast, and Im still running it in! (ie not allowed to take the revs over 4,000 for the first 1,250 miles). If you wish to slate a review here please make sure you have read it properly first.
<br>
<br>All the best,
<br>
<br>Adam
Reply to this comment
152996_Tommy224's Response to adamlondon69's Review
Written on: 25/04/2004
I agree, I think the mini is a fantastic car, I also think that through b roads there wouldn't be much between a Civic Type R and the cs, the mini offers supreme ride comfort and a stylish luxury interior.
Reply to this comment
Vtecpower200's Response to adamlondon69's Review
Written on: 31/12/2004
The Civic Type R is a far better car as it is a far cleverer shape and is actually worth what you pay for it. It has the following advantages over a puny Cooper S -
<br>1. More Powerful, thrilling experience taking it into VTEC Zone!
<br>2.Practicality, easily fit two 6ft+ adults in back. Also it actually has what i call a boot!
<br>3.Better build quality, even though mini's is still good.
<br>4.A Mini would not beable to keep up with it in any situation, especially on a track.
<br>
<br>In my opinion, when you buy a Mini Cooper S you are paying for the badge, BMW. Thats all, it should be at least £3000 cheaper than it is as it is so small and does not offer the practicality and Thrills as its competiton, e.g - The very good Clio 182 Cup which is about Two grand cheaper and also quicker.
<br>
<br>Also i think it is insane if anyone was to buy a Cooper S Works as that is totally over priced.
<br>Its ridiculus.
<br>Cooper S also do not feel as special as a Type R as you see them absolutly anywhere you look now.
Reply to this comment
Adamlondon69's Response to adamlondon69's Review
Written on: 02/01/2005
VTECPower200, hmm, I wonder what car you own... Suprisingly enough I agree with a fair bit of what you say. If you are out for a faster car then the Type R would be the one to get. My issue is that to get to the magical VTEC zone you have to go over 6,000 rpm, which is not very practical or economical for in-town/daily driving. Also, the steering gives little to no feed back and is far too light. Plus, your right, it is about the badge, and for some crazy reason I would rather drive a mini BMW than a chaved up Honda...
Reply to this comment
Vtecpower200's Response to adamlondon69's Review
Written on: 04/01/2005
Fair point but have you ever driven a Civic Type R, if you have you will know that when you use the VTEC you are really supposed to floor the accelerator, and in no time at all you are up to the 6,000 rpm mark, I agree, the power delivery is not all that practical in areas like going around town, but find a carriageway and you will see why people talk so highly of it.
<br>Oh and you pick at me about buying a Honda, well have you read about the VTEC engine, has there been a failure with one? No is the answer.
<br>I agree BMW is a very very good make, Honda may not be a prestige make like BMW, but they are certainly a very good make, and there reliability record shows that!!!!
<br>Is your Cooper S the standard 163BHP Supercharged version or have you had yours upgraded with the "John Cooper Works" package that takes it up to around 200BHP?
<br>Oh and for the comment "chaved up Honda" Try going on the Civic Type R reviews and writing that about it!
Reply to this comment
Nads205's Response to adamlondon69's Review
Written on: 05/01/2005
I think this is getting a little out of hand. Let me add my two pence worth.
<br>
<br>First off the Cooper S is nothing more than a fancy and rather tarty small BMW. And there's nothing wrong with that. There is obviously a big market for it however.
<br>
<br>Agreeing with my fellow Civic owner, the civic is far more of a serious sports car. Additionally, I don't think that the civic is any less sophisticated than the Cooper however. In fact I have been to some pretty posh weddings and the Silver Civic has commanded respect when parked next to the usual rich boys toys - 330ci, mercs etc etc. If I had a bright blue Cooper S there instead it just wouldn't have looked right - it's just too small and looks like a (nice) toy car.
<br>
<br>The civic is also far easier to live with (for example Ikea billy bookcases are no problem, nor are 5 tall adults), the Cooper is much smaller. For people like me who only have the one car and do need to occasionally carry stuff around the small space in the Cooper would be a definate problem.
<br>
<br>A good friend has driven my type r and compared it to his brother's Cooper S. I will get him to comment.
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“Going from an MX-5 to the new Cooper S, I was amazed...”
Written on: 02/11/2003 by Taren Kapel (1 review written)
Going from an MX-5 to the new Cooper S, I was amazed by the handeling capabilites and stop-start responsiveness. I loved the car from 30 minutes in my test drive, and within a day of taking delivery, I was able to take cornering ability of the S to it's limit (not that I am that good at driving, but the car is so easy to drive, and forgiving). The traction control is a great improvement over my old Morris Mini 'K', and coupled with the ABS, means I have not yet got into trouble (and I... (read more)
Shooter 1000's Response to Taren Kapel's Review
Written on: 05/03/2004
I am flabbergastted by the 18 slams on Mr. Oneill.
<br>
<br>I drove the S the first week they were introduced into the Washington, DC area for a weekend. Having admired the original Mini so much and having driven my friend\'s 60\'s version in the early 70\'s, I had high expectations for the car. Also, I have driven almost every iteration M3 and have found them truly exceptional cars. Truly 4 seat serious sports cars.
<br>
<br>Maybe I expected greatness (for its cost) due to it\'s predecessor\'s legendary legacy and I was truly pulling for it.
<br>
<br>Pull it did not. The gearing from 1st to 2nd gear was horrendous, just as Mr. Oneill stated. I was tremendously underwhelmed almost to the point of pain, by this major technical SNAFU. But it could not have been a mistake. The only answer is that the people with the last word on the final design must have engineered this into the car to turn off most serious drivers.
<br>
<br>I have one of the very first MX5s built, (called \"Miata\" here in the USA) made in 1989. A no frills, no power steering, no radio, base model 1.6 liter, but with a turbo, intercooler, Borla Turbo matched exhaust(Bell Engineering USA) with real life 190 BHP and 200 Ft/lb torque specs., installed in 1994. Also alloy wheels, z rated tire (tyres) and a serious suspension upgrade.
<br>
<br>The standard suspension even 15 years ago was easily better then that of the Cooper S\' at just between 1/2 to 2/3 the price adjusting for currency changes in time. Of course one is a true sports car, the other a sporty car. But with the serious tecnological advances in all the years, why doesn\'t the Mini handle better? Why as was already stated by another person, wasn\'t a turbo used instead? It seems that mainly the British and Americans use superchargers. Turbos are much more powerful and sophisticated by design, have virtually no lag now and generate no parasitic loss.
<br>
<br>I found the Mini Cooper S sloppy at high speeds in the corners and there was no allowance to steer by throttle, hampered by the lack of the anemics supercharger\'s ability to add any real assistance(why even bother with the supercharger?).
<br>
<br>I was a high performance bike rider for 17 years without owning one car in all those years. But I did work in the automotive field for 15 years and have driven virtually every sports/near race car including evirtually every iteration of the original (and new at the time) American muscle cars sold in the US since a teenager working for a huge performance garage starting in the late 60s.
<br>
<br>It is amazing how important useable power is when steering by throttle out of a corner. Is this a lost art and therefore not engineered into or understood by younger drivers? Also, there are so many intangibles and racing techniques that a Fangio or Shelby and so many other more experienced drivers would (have)understand intuitively that make a car mediocre to great. The Cooper S could have been a great car at the same cost. It is not the car it should have been and falls far short of a real world connectedness to driver and road that a truly enjoyable enthusiasts car should have. It does not have much soul. This is not to say that it is not a very nice car but it scrifices practicallity and rides too far on it\'s unrealized hype. A car this size, at this cost and with this legacy should have been far, far better.
Reply to this comment
159674_Johnscudder's Response to Taren Kapel's Review
Written on: 22/06/2004
Hello.... I've owned 4 Miata's.. and have loved their drivability. I understand what you and others are stating about using the throttle to pull out of a corner. I'm wondering however... can't you just downshift and apply the gas in the mini as well? I've done this on many test drives of the Mini S. It seemed to work, although I must admit that the WRX (Subaru) I'm also test driving pulls out without downshifting.
<br>
<br>John
Reply to this comment
166452_Archiejughead's Response to Taren Kapel's Review
Written on: 19/08/2004
I did try to downshift in my Mini S, and it only locked up the gearing... where I swirled around on the road only to hit the siderail! The car is not good.
Reply to this comment
★★★★★
“Having waited 11 months for delivery of our Mini...”
Written on: 22/10/2003 by ANTHONY WATKINS (1 review written)
Having waited 11 months for delivery of our Mini Cooper S from time of order my wife and I hoped it was going to be worth the wait, It was. My wife Dee drive for a living (she's in sales) so cars don't do that much for her untill she drove the cooper s, It has loads of smile factor.
Handling is superb (you will bottle out befor the car will) ride is very firm but thats what you would expect from a performance car, Fuel economy is good, build quality is what you would expect from BMW well put...
(read more)
★★★★★
“I test drove a loaded Mini Cooper S at my local...”
Written on: 02/10/2003 by quaddawg (1 review written)
I test drove a loaded Mini Cooper S at my local dealership. By the end of the ride (with my helpful salesman doing his spiel from the rear seat) my 8 year old son and I were grinning from ear to ear, and my S is on order this week... Really, my cheeks are still a little sore...... (read more)
Rpmmini's Response to quaddawg's Review
Written on: 18/11/2003
After reading all the mini cooper S's review and loving the car anyway i just got to say i wish i had a chance to drive/own one! happy motoring
Reply to this comment
★☆☆☆☆
“Really i hate it, dont even know why the Mini Cooper S...”
Written on: 18/09/2003 by rscossieboy (2 reviews written)
Really i hate it, dont even know why the Mini Cooper S was made really, it's so slow that even a fiat uno 1L had to under take me. why oh why was the mini ever made. such a shame really, cause they could of made a much better looking bean can. better luck next time. (read more)
Crofts11's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 20/09/2003
The mini cooper s is a very fast car, all i can say is just read what the expert say. I myself drive a cooper s and find the car exceptional. Most 2 liter cars can't keep up with the cooper s.
Reply to this comment
Ongske's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 21/09/2003
I dont agree with this review
Reply to this comment
Spinaltap19's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 22/09/2003
Does RS Cossie boy drive an RS Cosworth by any chance? Whilst there are plenty of hot hatches at the moment, most are just that, hot versions of a boring mass market look-alike family cars. The MINI Cooper S truly stands out from the rest by having a genuine sense of style and individuality, that is equally at home on the racetrack or B-road.
Reply to this comment
Quaddawg's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 02/10/2003
I dissagree wholeheartedly, the Mini S is a marvel of Technology and Simplicity at once, blended into the most fun a fellow could have on four wheels.. simply an amazing automobile, and by the way, I could overtake a Fiat uno on a bicycle...maybe a driving lesson is in order here?
Reply to this comment
Aris's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 03/10/2003
i cant take this review seriously!!! The mini S is definatly a fast car that handles marvelously!!
<br>
<br>The only bad points that i saw in the S was the quality of materials used and the reliability issues in some parts of the world.
Reply to this comment
Ollie9Inch's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 06/10/2003
You melt,u obviously dont no how to drive.You must be a northerner.....
Reply to this comment
Mcbrown's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 12/10/2003
RSCOSSIEBOY can't surely have driven one of these great cars! They take some 'running-in' to get the best out of them, but I've driven a number of examples and all have been quick and extremely well built. What other car on the road attracts the same number of admiring glances? Not the poorly styled and cheap-as-chips interior of any RS I can think of! Sure, it may not keep up with a Focus RS (??), but why would you want a 'peaky' car with a blue oval, when you can have the style, engineering nous, bullet-proof residuals and the point-to-point chuckability of a Cooper S, and save a few ££££s too!?
Reply to this comment
Minim's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 30/10/2003
This guy is crazy i have an S and i've ran against ( Nissan's Type R, Mitsus Evoc and Eclipes GSX, Honda 2000, and even a Ford Lightning) believe me the S kick ass. This guy probably does not know how to drive a German engineered auto mobile, he should stick to Japanes cars.
Reply to this comment
Burt's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 07/11/2003
I can only imagine that the originator of this article is missing out!!
Reply to this comment
Anthony Watkins's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 13/11/2003
This ladd is taking the mick, The car is very special as has been agreed by car specialist, it came out in the top ten performance cars with Evo Magazine on performance cars of the year.
<br>Everyone here who has responded to this idiot has proved the point, I can't believe his comment's were even printed, he must be a nurd.
Reply to this comment
Elizarenn's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 22/11/2003
It is so far off target that no one could possibly take it seriously.
Reply to this comment
Hales's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 11/12/2003
I think you must have your handbag stuck under the pedal? I have a CS and a S3 Audi and the CS out does the S3 on the B roads..Try pressing harder or changing gear...
Reply to this comment
Saint's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 26/12/2003
And you are Michael Schumacher or a F-16 pilot? Tell me the names of 1.6 lt.(litre for your information) cars over 163 hp(horse power).
<br>I'm not German but i can name you some German cars..BMW,Mercedes,Porsche,Audi,Wolksvagen.Think about it.
Reply to this comment
Davidcooper10's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 30/12/2003
I know that everyone is entitled to an oppinion but when you write a review like this just to undermine a car it should be deleted.
<br>
<br>From your comments I feel that you are jealous, and as for being undertook, DONT THINK SO !
<br>more likely this review is spawned from the embarrasment of your RS Boys Toy being OVER TOOK ! by a Mini Cooper S me thinks !
Reply to this comment
Mmarks's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 05/01/2004
I have owned Porche's, BMW's, Mercedes etc etc and now have a Mini Cooper S and I love it.
<br>
<br>The only other car that I have owned that was as much fun was a Porche SC Sport.
<br>
<br>The man needs to restrict himself to commenting on things that he understands.
Reply to this comment
Willr612's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 05/03/2004
If you feel that poorly about the MINI cooper S then you should\'ve kept your money. Just read the black and white and listen to the true motoring fanatics and you\'ll see it\'s all there. The MINI cooper S is an exceptional vehicle and a real joy to motor in.
Reply to this comment
Cyclingfrenzy's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 15/06/2004
well this is the 1st sad review I have seen. All I can say is the driver must be a VW salesman.
Reply to this comment
Sbonamo's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 17/07/2004
I agree the guy is a jerk. However, I take offense to the Northerner comment. 1st I am originally from NY, but now live in Texas, where these idiots should all be locked up and forced to take driving tests. 2nd, aren't England + Germany North, where some of the best handling/performance cars are made.
Reply to this comment
Fitz70's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 25/07/2004
This guy is definitely taking the mick and no further comment is warranted......
Reply to this comment
168220_Mini Mna's Response to rscossieboy's Review
Written on: 01/09/2004
He surely must have never owned one. In first gear as soon as the supercharger kicks in this car becomes a mini rocketship. The build is also excellenet and solid. Great handling and of course you can build it as you want it. Some are going to be better than others. But slow?? I don't think so.
Reply to this comment
See next 10 reviews
Showing 41 - 50 of 70 Reviews
overview
MoneySupermarket
Top 5 Modified Cars
To calculate the top 5's we take the following factors into account:
Brands
Top 5 Modified Cars
To calculate the top 5's we take the following factors into account:
• All the star ratings the company/product has received,
• The number of reviews
• How recent the reviews are
As rated by real users
-
1. Renault 5 GT Turbo
69 reviews read latest review -
2. Mini Cooper S
70 reviews read latest review -
3. Ford Fiesta Mk4 1.25 Zetec
67 reviews read latest review -
4. Peugeot 306 2.0 XSi
45 reviews read latest review -
5. Volkswagen Golf VR6
30 reviews read latest review
Hot Stuff in
Latest Reviews in Modified Cars
-
Vauxhall Corsa 1.0 12v litre
"Good" Read More
-
Volkswagen Golf VR6
"Old best car ever ( Vertical R..." Read More
-
Rover 620Ti
"Just paid £600 for my t..." Read More
-
Citroen ZX 2.0 16V
"Fast little car!" Read More
-
Suzuki Swift 16v GTi
"I've had mine for 4 years now ..." Read More
Latest items in Modified Cars
Brands
See All ▼
Hide All ▲
See more ▼
Guest's Comment
Written on: 09/05/2012
I love it so much！