Tony Parsons One For My Baby Reviews

Ken Rowley's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Report this review

Good Points: Very readable and emotionally moving. The characters are well-drawn, easy to identify with and the situations are realistic.

Bad Points: The 'plants' are telegraphed so that the plot sometimes appears like an identikit picture or a DIY knock-up.

General comments: Parsons' novels are written as if he has a 'How to write Novels' manual next to him all the time: the 'plants', that is the items that provide the plot twists and climaxes, are very easy to spot. However, his experience as a columnist means that the way he uses these plants and twists is not so obvious, and that makes for a very good read indeed. Many times in this and 'Man and Boy' I found myself moved by what Parsons had written and exclaimed that the novel has no right to be so good. What makes Parsons so successful is that he is so readable and we identify with his central characters and their comments on life.

johnny's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Report this review

I disagree with the general view of this book in that i prefer it to man and boy..it is aimed at adults so the themes tony p talks about seem to ring true, to me anyway..Although i haven't loved and lost to the extent Alfie has, the views expressed about love, casual sex, relationships and son on was excellent..The funeral description was awesome, the characters all interesting esp the Changs, the close relationship between Alfie and his parents funny and touching and accurate. The themes dwelle ...

On average, people found this review somewhat helpful
Report this review

A big disappointment as it is nowhere as good as his first book 'Man and Boy'.
Not suitable for teens either- casual sex between teacher and teenage students.
It is about coming to terms with the death of your partner who was your reason for living- an adult theme. Rings true for those who have loved and lost.