If you cut a round of cling film larger than your pot and press it lightly on the gel to expel all the air and then replace the lid it will keep from drying out

I am a lover of a good eyeliner with my favourite pencil being benefit bad gal, but I have never found a liquid eyeliner that will stay put without smudging onto my brow bone. After doing a lot of googling this eyeliner seem to come up as the best so I went in and bought it. Now don't get it me wrong it's a lovely texture and glides on very nicely. The assistant told me it was the blackest black but to be honest it is no blacker than any other. And even now I still having it melt and sometimes smudge onto my eye socket. Good, but I can't believe no one else has had the same issue.

Bobbi Brown Long-wear Gel Eyeliner is a great product when first opened. It is non-irritating, easy to apply, and stays put even during the hot humid summer months.

After being open it only lasts a couple of months before drying out and getting cakey. I only leave it open for a couple of seconds to dip my brush into and then recap. I now have several pots of gel that are 1/2 full and not able to be used. Ouch!

I brought this to the attention of the bobbi brown sales person, and they insist it is user error. I do not believe this to be true. Currently on the search for something that looks the same and works as well in another brand. Unfortunately only Bobbi has the color I like

Good product when its at its original consistency. Unfortunately, its hard to manipulate when it becomes dry.

I love the product but face the same problem of it drying out very quickly. So here I am sitting with several jars (all different colours) of dried, lumpy eyeliner which I hate to throw away. It's only barely used too.

Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner is fabulous! I have oily eyelids and have never found eyeliner that has staying power on me. This one does! Thumbs up for this product!

Bobbi Brown Long-wear Gel Eyeliner dries out VERY quickly. Sometimes you don't even use half the jar and it's too dry/clumpy to use. I probably leave the cap off for about 60 seconds while applying, which I don't think is too long at all. I complained to Macy's several times, and they have done nothing about it. They said you should only need to leave it open for a couple of seconds. Typical blame the consumer attitude.

I've used MAC and it doesn't dry out like BB. The only problem is that BB comes in a color I really like, which MAC does not.

Anybody from Bobbi Brown listening? You need to look at your formula and fix it.