LOreal Eyeliner Superliner Review

Watch this item
1.8 stars
Average rating for this product is: 1.8 out of 5

From 0 ratings and 12 reviews

Thumb down 33% of users recommend this product

Rate it Now:

Click on the stars above to rate this product:

Tweet This Item


Erica227's Review of LOreal Eyeliner Superliner

2nd Dec 2008

Overall Rating

1.5 stars
  • Value for money
    5 stars
  • Length of Use
    Over 6 months
  • Ease of Application
    5 stars
  • Durability
    I can't get it off!
  • Purchase Brand
    Regularly
  • Ease of Removal
    3.5 stars

I have been a faithful user of Loreal Eyeliner for years. I have always used the brown/black and loved it. I recently about almost 2 weeks ago went and purchased it in black. I applied it and within two hours I notice my eyes were burning and itchy. I continued to use it and now my eyes are super puffy and where I use my eyeliner is all red and flaky. It's really sad this had to happen as I love Loreal's eyeliner, but it's not worth using if I'm going to get this sort of reaction.

Remember - all reviews on Review Centre express the reviewer's opinion, not necessarily ours.
If you disagree with a review then please let us know by writing a review of your own or adding a comment.

Tweet This Review

Erica227's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!

How helpful did you find this review?


Members' Comments onErica227's Review

  • wrangham on 20th Aug 2009

    I had the same thing happen! I had worn Loreal eyeliner (black) for at least 10 years. In late 2007 I started having a problem with my eyelids swelling and itching, to the point that they actually peeled. I went to my opthalmologist, thinking I had an eye infection. The eye drops didn't work, and after a month of misery, I was referred to an allergist. I had a series of allergy tests, and the conclusion was an allergy to an ingredient found in hair color. I switched to a natural haircolor product, but the problem persisted. I was then referred to a dermatologist, who said it was a contact allergy to my eye make-up. Once I changed eyeliners, the problem went away. Loreal must have changed their eyeliner formula, as I never had the problem before. I wrote them for the ingredients in their eyeliner, and none were on the list of things I was allergic to? I loved the thin brush and ease of application, but it wasn't worth the itching.