Written on: 09/01/2004 by AWG (48 reviews written)
Incredibly researched publication.
Some opinions expressed.
I half expected Stephen E. Ambrose's version of the story of D-Day to be full of American jingoism. True, large sections are devoted to the USA build-up in the UK, and the Omaha and Utah landings. There are endless recollections from veterans who came "over here". I personally read with great affection and respect these accounts from USA service personnel.
But Ambrose's chapters PAYBACK about the Canadian offensive, and FAIRLY STUFFED WITH GADGETS - AN UNFORGETTABLE SIGHT - MY GOD, WE'VE DONE IT - etc., about the British offensive are also equally if not numerically riveting.
I personally find the author's back to back comparisons between Rommel and Eisenhower a bit of a lame duck, and I find the author's assessments of Bernard Law Montgomery both disagreeable re. El Alamein, and (regarding the stalling of the British Forces around Caen), highly offensive.
All in all a very good read, but not the definitive D-Day publication.
As rated by real users
" Pilgrims to Patriots is a must read!!! " Read More
" He was not a good person at all. Just because somebody was a POW do... " Read More
" The sort of history that will not be taught in school " Read More
Written by plappen
" The Lucifer Principle is a very clever point of view about where th... " Read More
" The Battle for the Normandy Beaches " Read More
Written by zerhem