freebsd - freebsd-stable review

Have a picture of FreeBSD - FreeBSD-STABLE?, please send it to us.

Average Ratings
Value for Money5/10
Overall rating8.2/10
83% Recommended5 out of 6 Reviews

expert review of FreeBSD - FreeBSD-STABLE

By XBSDUser. Rank: Lance Corporal on 29th Jul 2001

XBSDUser.'s Ratings
Value for money0/10
Overall value0/10
no XBSDUser.'s recommendation

Good Points

Easier to install than other bsd operating systems. Good for a single service server if you have it behind a firewall.

Bad Points

Unsecure, Not well maintained and unstable for desktop usage.

General Comments

I really have tried to give the freebsd project a chance but they seem to be hopeless. The project seems to concentrate more on new features than security and stability. This project seems to avarage two security advisories a week and with iso images only updated for the major releases by the time it hits the store self it already needs to be patched. Source on there ftp servers seems to also be well behind the security advisories. Works great for a server extreamly fast but it must currently be behind a firewall not very stable for desktop use overall I would say its fine if you want to pacth the kernal atleast three times a month and only wish to use it to serve a single service from behind a firewall. Wait for 5.0 coming out in the fall of 2001 or use OpenBSD 2.9 (Harder To Install) if security is an issue and it always is in networking, is'nt it?

Important, please be aware that:

  1. For each negative review there may be hundreds of satisfied customers.
  2. None of the information is validated by Review Centre. Reviews are the opinions of the individuals concerned. All Content published is moderated to meet our Terms and Conditions.
  3. We encourage companies to respond to negative reviews by using the comment facility at the bottom of the reviews.
Respect given for XBSDUser.'s review.
Helpful Unhelpful Agree Disagree
1 3 0 9

Total Respect: -11

How have you found this review?


3 Comments on Review by XBSDUser. for FreeBSD - FreeBSD-STABLE

  1. micke. on 12th Nov 2001

    This review is in my experience totally incorrect.

    FreeBSD is the most stable OS I have ever had the pleasure of interacting with. It just works.
    With servers running 200+ days I cannot but recommend FreeBSD to anyone wanting a reliable and secure platform.

    The FreeBSD security officer does not take his job lightly.
    The assumption that FreeBSD is insecure only because of
    patches appearing is wrong. With almost 6000 external programs included in the "ports" mechanism some of them are bound to have security problems. I am glad that I am notified before havoc strikes. Almost every security problem stems from the external software not the OS in itself. If you have not installed the "port" in question you are in the clear.
    The base install has three levels of security - just select the proper one for your site.

    The ease at which I can update my system(s) through source code and recompilation makes updates very easy and painless.

    I have run a lab with 50+ dualboot FreeBSD/Windows machines for the last five years, with one (1) FreeBSD server with NFS, DNS, web, ftp and fileserver serving the entire lab. No it is not
    choking - it just works!

    In this environment people use FreeBSD for their normal desktop needs too. FreeBSD is not just a server OS.

    To anyone contemplating which OS to use: At least give FreeBSD a try. I did and have not looked back since.

  2. Joseph. on 6th Dec 2001

    I totally DISAGREE with the review posted. I use Linux and FreeBSD and have different opinion on both. As a measure of performance/stability of FreeBSD as desktop OS try to do the following (simultaneously) and decide for yourself :

    Play an MP3 with XMMS and Copy a Full CD to the HDD, do image manipulation with gimp,Click the home directory icon a few times, start another VT and start another X, start Netscape and Click the home directory icon a few times.... I never had a problem, not even once !

    Yes, you have to do a little bit tweaking and tuning for optimum performance/disk IO. But, it's as easy as it can get and Kernel re-compilation is easiest of all *NIX.

    From 4.4 Release onwards, most Software is available as packages on ISO CD images for download.

    If you have not tried FreeBSD, you are definitly missing something. What's the harm in trying ?

  3. Ttimrawi on 30th Jan 2004

    I've been using FreeBSD O/S for more than 4 years. More than 500IP's assigned to each box with no less than 500 users running processes and 1000 processes running on the system at all time using no more than 1GB of RAM and an AMX XP2000. Not to mention www/ftp/named/ipfw/ident.

    These servers where used for IRC clients and the business it self attract alot of Denial of Services attacks. Yet I've never seen my system crashing before.

    I beleive FreeBSD is the best Free UNIX distribution so far. I would definetly disagree with this review.



Top Operating Systems
Apple Mac OS X (10.2)
Debian Debian GNU/Linux 3.1 (sarge)
Libra Systems LibraNet 2.7
Mandriva Linux "Mandrake" 10.0-10.1
Microsoft Plus! for Windows XP
Microsoft Windows XP
Microsoft Windows XP Upgrade
Novell Netware 3.12
Sun Solaris 10
Windows XP Professional Edition
Windows XP Professional Edition Upgrade
Xandros 1.0 Desktop
Requested reviews
HP-UX 11.23
Linux Linspire 5
Linux Mandrake 9.2 Powerpack
SuSE Linux 9.0 Personal
SuSE Linux 9.0 Professional
Virtual PC 7.0
Virtual PC for Mac 6.1
Windows 2000 Professional Product Upgrade
Windows 2000 Professional Version Upgrade
Windows Small Business Server Standard 2003 CD/DVD 5 Client

Would you like to see a review that's not being listed?

View 17 more

Web Results
freebsd-stable Info Page
freebsd-stable -- Production branch of FreeBSD source code...

lists.freebsd.org
FreeBSD-CURRENT vs. FreeBSD-STABLE
There are two development branches to FreeBSD: FreeBSD-CURRENT and FreeBSD-STABLE. ... FreeBSD-CURRENT will be discussed first, then FreeBSD-STABLE.

www.freebsd.org
FreeBSD - FreeBSD-STABLE Review - Operating Systems. Review of 2416
FreeBSD - FreeBSD-STABLE in Operating Systems / Computer Software reviews at Review Centre...

www.reviewcentre.com
FreeBSD - FreeBSD-STABLE Review - Operating Systems. Review of 6548
FreeBSD - FreeBSD-STABLE in Operating Systems / Computer Software reviews at Review Centre...

www.reviewcentre.com