doctor who review

Have a picture of Doctor Who?, please send it to us.
Picture courtesy of The Daleks.

Average Ratings
Value for Money7.2/10
Reviewer Rating7.2/10
Overall Rating7.7/10 Based on 6 ratings
80% Recommended4 out of 5 Reviews

expert review of Doctor Who

By Tom H Rank: Military Police on 16th Feb 2007

Tom H's Ratings
Starring (Main Performers)Christopher Eccleston, Billie Piper
Value for money8/10
Overall value8/10
yes Tom H's recommendation

Good Points

Everything. From writing, to directing, and to acting - everything in the new series is brilliant

Bad Points

There aren't any. This is British TV at its' absolute best.

General Comments

Spanning three decades, Doctor Who was one of those shows that never failed to pull viewers. With rickety sets, initially poor editing, over-acting from guest stars and low-budget special effects bordering on laughable (green painted bubble-wrap was a favourite in the mid 1970's, and if you look hard enough in the old black and white ones you can see camera shadows on walls and even badly hidden boom microphones hovering above actors), somehow, it outlived the expectations of everyone.
Funny that the first episode had to be repeated because many missed its first broadcast and were desperate to see this bizarre "human" with a time machine. And the rest is part of TV history. Seven lead actors, millions of fans, videos galore, and fan conventions spanning the globe.

So, when life-long fan and writer-producer Russell T Davies had the chance to re-invent the classic for the 21st century, I wonder if he realised just how big it would become?
Initial work established much, including the financial support of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation and BBC Wales. But, who would play the universe's favourite Time Lord?
Reports say that Bill Nighy was a hot tip, but Russell T Davies approached Salford-born thespian Christopher Eccleston, star of "Cracker" and Davies' mini series "Second Coming," to play the Doctor.
And what a choice! Eccleston played the Doctor so well that he came very close to eclipsing Bill Hartnell and Tom Baker as the favourite incarnation. His comedic timing, strong acting skills, and insistence that the Doctor should be a Lancastrian, won millions of new fans, as well as bringing the already established "Whovians" out of the woodwork.
Support was provided by former pop star Billie Piper as Rose Tyler, a tough 18-year-old who gets caught up by accident in an attempted Auton/Nestene invasion. Piper's casting raised eyebrows (bearing in mind Georgia Moffat, daughter of the fifth Doctor, Peter Davison, auditioned but didn't make it) as an untrained actress, but proved her skills.
Revival of the infamous Daleks brought many more fans out, especially as it was revealed the Time Lords and Daleks had fought a bloody war (the "Time War," which becomes the longest story thread in the new version of Doctor Who) and the Doctor is the only survivor (until we find the Daleks had an escape plan ). The classic sink-plunger, combined with grating voice, brought a new legion of fans for the most-feared dustbins in the Universe.
The introduction of the former Time Agent Captain Jack Harkness (played by John Barrowman) even brought about a spin-off centering around Harkness' involvement with alien investigators Torchwood (the name being an anagram of "Doctor Who") showed Russell T Davies to be a master storyteller. The man deserves awards galore.
The series (which is cleverly written - listen out for the name "Bad Wolf" in every episode and see how it becomes pivotal in the series finale), ends in a spectacular two-part story where the Daleks launch their final attack on the Earth, which incorporates the most amazing CGI sequence ever seen on British TV.

Tom H's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!

How have you found this review?


2 Comments on Review by Tom H for Doctor Who

  1. Anonymous101 Rank: Major-General on 19th Feb 2007

    Never watched one episode, never will.

  2. themaninthevan2001 Rank: Major on 20th Feb 2007

    I used to watch Doctor Who once. They are still great classics, but the new Doc left too soon, and it seems Piper wants to leave, and the rest maybe.



Top Science Fiction Shows
Battlestar Galactica
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Charmed
Doctor Who
Enterprise
Quantum Leap
Stargate SG1
Requested reviews
Star Trek

Would you like to see a review that's not being listed?

View 1 more

Hot Stuff in Science Fiction Shows
Doctor Who in Science Fiction Shows
Web Results
STARTREK.COM
Currently featuring Enterprise, the latest in the Star Trek series. Includes news, interviews, cast biographies, episode guide...

www.startrek.com
Janet's Star Trek Voyager Site is now at www.star-trek-voyager.net - ...
Includes images, dictionary, database, games and episode guides. ... The site's BRIDGE (homepage) is now at www.star-trek-voyager.net/index.htm You will be automatically beamed there in:

www. star-trek-voyager .fsnet.co.uk
STAR TREK

www.startrekuk.co.uk
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
Episode summaries, TV showings, video releases. ... Star Trek, Star Trek: The Next Generation, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, ...

www.ee.surrey.ac.uk