the outsider, edinburgh review

Average Ratings
Quality of service3.7/10 Based on 16 ratings
Quality of food6.1/10 Based on 20 ratings
Value for Money5.6/10
Reviewer Rating4.6/10
Overall Rating4.8/10 Based on 26 ratings
52% Recommended12 out of 23 Reviews

Review of The Outsider, Edinburgh

By JuliaD on 4th Feb 2007

JuliaD's Ratings
Food TypeModern European
Average cost per head£10 - £25
How often do you eat here?Once or twice a year
AtmosphereLively
Quality of service4/10
Quality of food8/10
Value for money7/10
Overall value4/10
yes JuliaD's recommendation

Good Points

The food is excellent! It was well presented and good value for money.
There is a good range of wines available.
Great location, although if you don't know it's there, it is difficult to spot from outside.

Bad Points

Noisy - whilst the modern decor is very subtle and well done, there are no soft furnishings or fabrics to absorb the noise. Don't go with anyone who is hard of hearing.
Staff - the 'waiting' staff were all friendly, attentive and well mannered, but the two gentleman who were managing the bookings and seating could do with a lesson in how to communicate with customers without appearing to be rude.
Coats policy - there is a policy to remove outdoor coats, and I can understand totally that it is not practical or safe to have coats hanging on the back of chairs. The storage for coats however, is a large 'pigeon -hole' (for your table) into which coats are bundled in a large ball. Don't take anything which is liable to get crushed or need ironing afterwards.
Toilets - these are downstairs, therefore you have to fight your way through the people coming in and out, and those putting coats on and off to get there. The ladies is quite small, and there are no mirrors for touching up hair and make-up, which aren't above hand-basins. It can therefore be a bit crowded when people are trying to wash their hands as well.

General Comments

We were shown promptly to our table, but we were not asked for our choices for about 20 minutes. Any upmarket restaurant (which this is obviously trying to be) would suggest or offer drinks whilst looking at the menu, but this was not done. The wine eventually arrived, but it was placed on the table without a word - at an average of £15 a bottle, I would have expected to be offered a taste by the waitress prior to pouring.

My husband was asked rather abruptly to move his chair in so that the waitress could get past. This he did without any comment, but can I suggest that maybe they have too many tables in the allocated space? On a previous visit in a larger party of 14, we were told that we were sitting at 2 separate tables. We were OK about that, but one was on the mezzanine floor and one on the ground!
Don't get me wrong, we really enjoyed our meal, but having looked at many similar comments on this restaurant, why has no-one from The Outsider done anything or commented back on their behalf?

Important, please be aware that:

  1. For each negative review there may be hundreds of satisfied customers.
  2. None of the information is validated by Review Centre. Reviews are the opinions of the individuals concerned. All Content published is moderated to meet our Terms and Conditions.
  3. We encourage companies to respond to negative reviews by using the comment facility at the bottom of the reviews.
Respect given for JuliaD's review.
Helpful Unhelpful Agree Disagree
0 0 1 0

Total Respect: +1

How have you found this review?


1 Comment on Review by JuliaD for The Outsider, Edinburgh

  1. taylor9991 Rank: Captain on 4th Feb 2007

    I love Scotland. I'll keep this in my mind. Many thanks.



Top Scottish Restaurants
Abstract, Inverness
Acanthus, Perth
Calistoga, Edinburgh
India of Inchinnan, Renfrewshire
Let's Eat, Perth
McKirdys, Edinburgh
The Dining Room, Brechin
The Village Inn, Arrochar
Urban Angel, Edinburgh
Victorias, Pitlochry
  • A Gringo's Guide to Authentic Mexican Cooking (Cookbooks and Restaurant Gui...
  • Vegi-Mex Cookbook (Cookbooks and Restaurant Guides) by Lee Fischer - Golden...
  • Mexican Family Favorites Cook Book (Cookbooks and Restaurant Guides) by Mar...

View 17 more

Web Results
Wine-Searcher
Find and price any wine. Searchable database of 9,111 wine merchants' price lists. Locate which wine stores stock specific wines and compare prices. ... To search for a wine: Enter either the name (e ...

www. wine-searcher .com
Wine Online - Wine Gifts and celebration Packs - Buy wine on line
Welcome to the UK's best wine web site offering wine online at the best possible prices. With our superb service offering a vast selection of wine from all varieties including Red wine, White Wine , ...

www.winecellar.co.uk
Majestic Wine - Homepage
The UK's biggest and best mixed case wine retailer offers online ordering with free delivery, award-winning service and market-leading deals. homepage ... Welcome to Majestic Wine, ...

www.majestic.co.uk
Oddbins Wine Merchant
Wines and spirits. On-line ordering, wine recommendations and wine guide. ... It?s always handy to have a reference for what you can expect in different grape varieties when choosing wine.

www.oddbins.com