Have a picture of A History of Violence?, please send it to us.
| Value for Money | 6.7/10  |
|---|---|
| Overall rating | 6/10 |
By Timix1
on 21st Nov 2005
| Starring Actor/Actress | Viggo Mortensen, Ed Harris, Maria Bello, William H |
|---|---|
| Where Did You See It? | Cinema |
| Value for money | 5/10 |
| Overall value | 5/10 |
 Timix1's recommendation | |
A solid Viggo Mortensen and a memorable cameo by William Hurt.
Awkward shifts in tone and mood that distract from the story.
A History of Violence is one of the hottest tickets at this year ' s Toronto International Film Festival was this latest offering by Canadian director David Cronenberg. It may have entered the city with mostly mixed reviews from its official debut in Cannes back in May, but it left the metropolis riding a virtual wave of raves from North American critics quick to praise its unflinching look at a culture that makes our primal inclinations towards violence rise to the surface with shocking facility. With over three hundred movies to choose from and having little advance info on the lion ' s share of the festival ' s schedule, I eagerly stood in line on a beautiful September morning for an early taste of what was sure to be one of this fall ' s most talked-about pieces of cinema.
With a script based on a graphic novel by John Wagner and Vince Locke, A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE focuses on the Stall family of sleepy Millbrook, Indiana. Tom (Viggo Mortensen), wife Edie (Maria Bello) and their two kids have carved out a life of idyllic Midwestern bliss, one where the local sheriff is always your friend, neighbours look out for one another, and the best slice of pie you ' ve had in your life can be found just down the street at the local diner. While the seemingly mild-mannered patriarch prepares to close shop one night at said diner, a pair of armed robbers attempt to make trouble when out of nowhere Tom switches into Arnold Schwarzenegger from TERMINATOR and quickly " and brutally " dispenses of the threat. Proclaimed a hero by locals and the media alike, the incident soon draws the attention of some Philadelphia mobsters - led by a menacing Ed Harris - who ride into town convinced that they ' ve found a rival wiseguy named Joey Cusack who ' s got unfinished business back in Philly. Tom vehemently denies any association with these lowlifes, but his recent behaviour has even his doting spouse question whether she truly knows her husband of twenty years.
As the big-city toughs intensify their pressure on the family, the Stalls 'Norman Rockwell-like existence begins to unravel. Suddenly, Tom ' s likable but nerdish teenage son, Jack (Ashton Holmes) finds the 'eye of the tiger '- or something - within him as he finally cracks under the pressure of a bully ' s taunts.
Claims that HISTORY is the director ' s stab at mainstream success are presumably due to his choice of fixing his critical eye on Middle America as opposed to, say, 'auto ' -erotic fetishists in CRASH or maniacal twin gynaecologists in DEAD RINGERS. His love of dark humour and pushing buttons within his audience has always served his past choice of material well. Here, it causes a rather dramatic shift in tone midway through that made me feel like I was watching two different movies at once. Scenes of compelling human drama are interspersed with more farcical ones, most notably in a climatic encounter between Tom and a mafia kingpin (a memorably hammy William Hurt) that borders on slapstick. Hurt ' s extended cameo is richly enjoyable on its own terms, but as part of the bigger fabric of HISTORY, I couldn ' t help but wonder how the film ' s disparate jigsaw puzzle pieces were meant to fit together. So much so that I ' m strongly tempted to watch the movie again now that it has reached local theatres, solely for the purpose of trying to uncover what film critics found so mesmerizing.
It ' s not that I hated A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE by any means; strong performances and provocative social commentary abound. No, I ' m afraid it ' s far worse than that: I don ' t seem to entirely get it. Sigh. Then again, as I think back to another balmy morning later that same week in Toronto as I awaited another screening, a film buff from California who was making her maiden festival visit echoed my disappointment. Here ' s a lady who was a veteran frequenter of that Mecca of independent filmmaking, the Sundance Film Festival. Surely, she knew what she was talking about. Right? RIGHT?!
Timix1's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!
Would you like to see a review that's not being listed?
