the island review

Have a picture of The Island?, please send it to us.
Picture courtesy of Crazy Chick.

Average Ratings
Value for Money5.3/10
Overall rating6.3/10
33% Recommended1 out of 3 Reviews

Review of The Island

By britcitchris Rank: Lieutenant on 21st Aug 2005

britcitchris's Ratings
Starring Actor/ActressEwan McGregor, Scarlet Johannson
Where Did You See It?Cinema
Value for money8/10
Overall value8/10
yes britcitchris's recommendation

Good Points

Plenty of fast flowing, breath taking action

Bad Points

The sci fi element is poor.

General Comments

Loosely based on the sublime book "Spares" by Michael Marshall Smith, The Island is the story of one man's quest to discover the real but hidden world. Realizing he is just a clone for spare parts, he escapes his artificial world and embarks upon a journey to find his real counter part, taking a female friend (and clone) with him. Director Michael Bay (Armageddon,The Rock)keeps the action thick and fast and there's a car chase that's almost as exciting as the one in Matrix:Reloaded. Disappointingly though, the sci fi element of the film is a let down. There are two very different styles here and they don't mix. Using present day vehicles against a futuristic back drop just doesn't work and presents quite a clash. The Island gives only the faintest of nods to the story line of the book and instead, turns the story into a hi tech chase film. The thought provoking and very intelligent writing have been over looked sadly but Ewan McGregor and Scarlet Johansson give good performances and it's always fun to see Steve Buscemi on the screen, providing the comic relief. Overall, The Island is great fun and presents some very exciting action. Switch off your brain before watching and you should enjoy it. Great fun.

britcitchris's review has yet to be rated - Be the first!

How have you found this review?




Top Science Fiction & Fantasy Films
Beowulf
Cloverfield Reviews
Equilibrium
Hellboy (12a)
Jumper Reviews
Mr Magorium's Wonder Emporium
Star Wars Trilogy (Episodes IV-VI)
Stardust
The Dark Knight
The Golden Compass
Requested reviews
Alien Quadrilogy
Love Story 2050
Men In Black Collector's Edition
Star Trek XI (2008)
The Crow
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (Extended Edition)
The Seeker: The Dark Is Rising
The X-Files: I Want to Believe
When Worlds Collide
Willow

Would you like to see a review that's not being listed?

View 16 more

Hot Stuff in Science Fiction & Fantasy Films
Science Fiction & Fantasy Films
  1. Cloverfield Reviews
  2. Star Trek XI (2008)
  3. The Dark Knight
  4. The X-Files: I Want to Believe

Similar Price Science Fiction & Fantasy Films

  1. Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines (about £5)
  2. Ladyhawke (about £7)
  3. Timeline (about £5)
  4. X-Men 3: The Last Stand (about £5)
  5. Them (about £7)
  6. 20 Million Miles To Earth (about £5)
  7. The Time Machine (1960 Original) (about £5)
  8. Doctor Who - Tomb Of The Cybermen (about £7)
  9. First Men In The Moon (about £5)
  10. The Day The Earth Caught Fire (about £7)

Web Results
science fiction books, out of print books, rare books, used ...
specialists in science fiction books, fantasy books, horror books, crime books, thriller, ghost books, magazines and fanzines, from rare first editions to secondhand and used paperbacks.

www. fantasticliterature .com
Science Fiction and Fantasy Book List
Bibliography of science-fiction and fantasy authors and their books. Database also contains links to official and fan sites of various authors where they exis...

www.sfbooklist.co.uk
The SF Site: The Best in Science Fiction and Fantasy
Includes numerous book reviews, news, links to related resources, and also hosts the websites of various science fiction and fantasy e-zines.

www.sfsite.com
science fiction, fantasy and horror from infinity plus
Short stories, novel extracts, reviews, features... infinity plus showcases the work of some of the world's top science fiction and fantasy authors.

www. infinityplus .co.uk
ULTIMATE SCIENCE FICTION WEB GUIDE
ALMOST SIX THOUSAND LINKS TO WEB SCIENCE FICTION RESOURCES! The 'Ultimate Science Fiction Web Guide' is the largest on-line encyclopedia of science fiction, with over 9,396 Science Fiction ...

www.magicdragon.com
Science Fiction Books, Star Wars Books, Graphic Novels, Fantasy ...
The Science Fiction Book Club offers discount books including science fiction novels and science fiction art selections. The Sci-fi Book Club provides great prices on all sci-fi books.

www.sfbc.com
Science Fiction and Fantasy World - sffworld.com
Science Fiction and Fantasy authors with biography, bibliography, news, book reviews, interviews, articles and links. Features large number of articles of interest to science fiction and fantasy ...

www.sffworld.com
Baen Books Science Fiction& Fantasy - Home Page
Baen is the specialist science fiction imprint started by Jim Baen. Site has a free e-books archive of their authors' in-print work...

www.baen.com
Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, Inc.
The official website of the premier professional science fiction writer's association. The SFWA site contains membership information, links to members sites, markets, and sample contracts.

www.sfwa.org
Locus Online: Science Fiction News, Reviews, Resources, Perspectives
Notable new SF/F/H books available the second week of July include Gardner Dozois's The Year's Best Science Fiction: Twenty-fifth Annual Collection, David Louis Edelman's MultiReal, new Robert A. ...

www.locusmag.com