diana p5 magnum review

Have a picture of Diana P5 Magnum?, please send it to us.
Picture courtesy of norcal38.

Average Ratings
Value for Money8/10
Reviewer Rating8/10
Overall Rating8.1/10 Based on 31 ratings
83% Recommended20 out of 24 Reviews

Review of Diana P5 Magnum

By Mad Dog Rank: Major on 11th Feb 2005

Mad Dog's Ratings
Value for money9/10
Overall value9/10
yes Mad Dog's recommendation

Good Points

Powerful, accurate, two stage trigger (both stages adjustable), fully adjustable fiber optic sights, easy and fun to use, comfortable grips, nice looking pistol.

Bad Points

It seemed to take quite a few shots to break-in, but after a couple tins of pellets it smoothed out and settled down nicely.

General Comments

At first I didn't know what to think about my .177 Diana P5 Magnum; heavy recoil, quite high cocking effort, and lots of vibration. The thing kicked so hard it almost yanked itself out of my hand. But I didn't give up, and kept shooting it. After about 300 rounds it started to settle down and kick a little less and also seemed a little easier to cock while still hitting the target with alot of energy. Through the next tin of pellets the gun proceeded to settle in further and after about 700 rounds it became a joy to shoot. Cocking the gun became a lot easier and the recoil was much more relaxed, as well as reduced vibration, while power actually seemed to have stayed the same or even improved. After this long break-in period I decided to dismantle it and clean, debur and relube the guide and mainspring with moly paste, along with a very thin coat on the inside and outside of the piston, and anywhere else there was moving parts. Now the vibration is hardly noticable and the forward recoil is quite mild compared to the first hundred or so shots when the gun kicked wildly and buzzed with vibration. My patience and attention to detail paid off and I've ended up with a very smooth hard hitting pistol that surprizes me with its accuracy even though it is a break barrel. I did have to learn to shoot this gun, just like I did with my Webley Hurricane, only the P5 has a forward recoil instead of the rearward recoil I had to figure out with the Hurricane. Just like most other spring powered airguns finding the propper grip tension is vital to shooting it accurately. If you try to fight the recoil of this gun you will likely end up frustrated, letting it do its thing gave me very good 10 meter accuracy, while gripping it tightly and trying to hold it still gave quite poor results. The two stage trigger is great, it was easy to adjust both stages to my liking and is light and predictable. The sights are nice to, especially in low light conditions. The rear is click adjustable with a flat head screwdriver and the front post is drift adjustable for windage. My gun was manufactured in Feb. 2004 and has no safety, I found this a little odd seeing as how the gun is advertized to have an auto saftey, but it is also advertized with a 700fps velocity which is also unrealistic and shouldn't be expected, mid 500's is a reasonable expectation. This pistol is big, 18 inches in legnth and weighs in at about 2.5lbs. The sytnetic grips have a comfortable thumb shelf and were disigned for a large hand, if they were any bigger they would not fit my hand. I now have over 1000 rounds through my P5, and have had it a little longer than two months and I couldn't be more pleased with it. I recommend this pistol to anyone with large hands and a lot of patience since the wear-in time is quite long. I must add that the gun responds very well to a strip down and re-lube, making loading and firing even smoother. To me, well worth the money and time spent.

Respect given for Mad Dog's review.
Helpful Unhelpful Agree Disagree
3 0 1 0

Total Respect: +4

How have you found this review?


7 Comments on Review by Mad Dog for Diana P5 Magnum

  1. Airgunfun Rank: Sergeant on 19th May 2005

    I own the Diana P5 pistol in .22 cal. You definitely do not grip this gun tight. When holding this gun to fire, use the golf grip analogy: Pretend you're gripping a canary. Too tight and you will crush it to death. Too loose and it will fly away. I started with Dynamit Noble 14.5gr Super-H-point pellets. A little slow but with a good wallop and accuracy. I tried the Dynamit Noble 11.9gr Hobby pellets. A substantial increase in velocity and punch out to 10 yards. Flatter trajectory with good accuracy. My gun is new and is still being broken in but I'm starting to notice changes such as it shooting smoother with less vibration. Lots of fun plinking cans or paper target with enough punch in .22cal to flatten other items of more density. I started with airguns when I was very young. I switched to firearms and still have a couple but at age 48, I'm hooked again on airguns. Costs a bit but the P5 Diana air pistol (c/w steel trigger-not plastic, like there is on the model 24 and 36 rifle) is very well made. Highly recommended.

  2. Mindflayer Rank: Corporal on 29th Dec 2005

    How do you like it compared to the Hurricane? Which would you prefer?

  3. Mad Dog Rank: Major on 4th Jan 2006

    I like the Hurricane alot, but the extra power and superior accuracy of the P5 make my choice easy.

    Mad Dog

  4. Dual Mag Mike Rank: Major on 6th Feb 2006

    Have you even tried to chronograph your gun or are you just guessing at the velocity? To try to guess or estimate a pellets velocity and buck a velocity claim is just wierd. Buy or borrow a chrony and due the test. If the gun happens to clock far less than the manufacturers claims send it back maybe you got a bad gun. My gun clocks 613 fps. with Silver Bears and 654 with Prometheus pellets and I don't even have 2 tins of pellets through the gun. There are claims of velocity improvements up to some 1500 pellets and or a well broken in gun.

  5. Mad Dog Rank: Major on 26th Feb 2006

    Hey settle down there! I'm not trying to bash this fine pistol. Mine is healthy and is spot on with the Diana (manufacturer) velocity rating which is 175mps or 574fps depending on pellet weight. The importer (RWS) claims 213mps or 700fps, hmm, that's weird not me! I don't guess velocity and I don't use pellets that are under 8gr so I'll never see, nor do I care to see the velocity you're getting. I'm more interested in hitting what I aim at than getting the big velocity numbers. An airgun gaining velocity through break in is nothing new, I've seen it happen quite a few times. It can also go the other way though, it depends on the gun and manufacturer. Mad Dog

  6. Dual Mag Mike Rank: Major on 2nd Mar 2006

    The gun is capable of 700 fps. and can and should be expected (at least close to it ). Again sellers will report optimum results under optimum conditions. Accuracy with Silver Bear pellets is not a problem at all. You do not, "have to" use 8 gr. or heavier pellets to hit what you are aiming at. Agreed that it is a fine gun but people have tried to discredit the 700 fps. numerous times and I would like people to know that the velocity IS there!!

  7. Mad Dog Rank: Major on 3rd Mar 2006

    If high velocity is your goal, that's fine, I have no problems with that. I don't know why you quoted "have to" use 8gr or heavier ammo, I "choose" to use 8gr or heavier because with a certain 8gr match the pellet I get best accuracy from my P5 and many other airguns I own. I choose specific ammo for any airgun by finding the most accurate pellet for the gun, peroid. I'm sure you already know that every bore has a pellet preference, also that every shooter has different ideals of performance. I wrote an unbiased review of my pistol and I don't expect everyone to agree with it....ahh, the sweet taste of individuality. Enjoy your hobby for what it is, I am. Good shooting to ya, Mad Dog



Top Air Pistols
Anics Anics Skif A-3000
Baikal IZH-46M
Beeman P3
Crosman 1377c
Crossman 1008 Repeater
Marksman Model 2004
SMK S2 .177
Walther NightHawk
Webley & Scott Hurricane
Weihrauch HW45 or Beeman P1
Requested reviews
Springfield Centimetre M1911 A1 - GAS Bio Colour
Springfield Nastoff .45 - GAS Black
Beeman FWB C55
Beretta 92
Beretta M93R
Beretta U22 Neos DLX
Colt Peacemaker
Gat .177 Air Pistol
Smith & Wesson 4505
Smith & Wesson 78G

Would you like to see a review that's not being listed?

Hot Stuff in Air Pistols
Crosman 1377c in Air Pistols

Similar Spec Air Pistols

  1. Diana SP50
  2. Diana 5G
  3. Diana P5 Magnum
  4. Diana 6M
  5. Diana MkII
  6. Diana MK4 pistol
  7. Daisy Powerline 008

Web Results
Air guns - Pyramyd Air Report: Diana P5 Magnum air pistol from RWS
by B.B. Pelletier The posting on the difference between the Webley Tempest and Hurricane pistols generated a little interest in another powerful spring pistol, the Diana P5 Magnum.

www.pyramydair.com
Diana RWS 5G Magnum P5. Air guns - PyramydAir.com
Diana RWS 5G Magnum P5. Air guns. The<b>Diana RWS P5</b> pistol is a spring piston action airgun. It has excellent accuracy at a reasonable price. Comes standard with a two stage trigger, fiber optic...

www.pyramydair.com
Diana P5 Magnum Review - Air Pistols. Review of 27402
Diana P5 Magnum in Air Pistols / Shooting reviews at Review Centre ... Read carefully what I say : This Diana P5 Magnum Air pistol is the most powerful pistol on the market (rated at 175 m/s !). ...

www.reviewcentre.com
Diana P5 Magnum Review - Air Pistols. Review of 113747
Diana P5 Magnum in Air Pistols / Shooting reviews at Review Centre ... I agree with other reviewers who question the power-rating of the Diana P5 Magnum gun.

www.reviewcentre.com