Use the tools below to refine your search by only displaying reviews with a certain number of star ratings or to only show reviews from a certain time period. Eg click on '1 star' to just display the reviews we have which received a 1 star rating click or 'Within the last month' to display just reviews posted over the last month.
Written on: 16/07/2012
Black magic used to be my favourite chocolates. I was given a box of the Black Magic Classic Favourites and was very disappointed. The cream ones were completely different and the chocolate on them all not as gppd. This is very disappointing as I only like dark chocolate. Bring back the old recipe!!!… Read Full Review
Written on: 11/05/2012 by patchoc (1 review written)
My husband bought me a box of Black Magic recently.....and my heart sank! Black Magic chocolates used to be my most favourite chocolates and I knew all the flavours and for me, they surpassed every other chocolate on the market. Since Nestle changed them from 12 flavours to 6, there is no comparison to what we had years ago. Who on earth wants a huge box of chocolates with only 6 flavours - I threw most of them in the bin! I used to love the Coffee Cream and Toffee and Mallow most of all… Read Full Review
Written on: 05/04/2012
Just opened a box of chocs today St Patrick's Day 2012. I was very disappointed with the selection.They just don' make them like they used to.I'd love to know does anyone seriously like orange creams???? Where did the nut clusters go, probably too much bother therefore cost more to make them. Not a caramel in sight either. I don't think I'll be buying what was my favourite in the future. Unfortunately nothing to like anymore. With regret Ann… Read Full Review
Written on: 05/01/2012 by MONTY2011 (1 review written)
I noticed a slight improvement this year on the box design and selection, however, they are by no means what they used to be. Remember the days of 'who knows the secret of the black magic box'? Over here in Canada, they were selling them of after christmas for a $1.89 per box. They simply could not sell them. Until I see a visible attempt at widing back the clock 20 years, Nestle can go jump!… Read Full Review
Written on: 03/01/2012 by jennniferraw (1 review written)
Black Magic completely downgraded. Why change an exceptional product? Where are the hazelnut cluster, turkish delight, nougat, coffee cream. butterscotch, brazil nut, etc. Even the chocolate is not the same hard, dark consistancy. Gave two boxes for Christmas and kept one for a treat for myself. Hugely disappointing, shall not buy any more. Nestle; WAKE UP !… Read Full Review
Written on: 26/12/2011 by snomad (1 review written)
You had an opportunity to sell a premium product at a premium price but instead chose to destroy a loved brand with an established following. What sort of idiots do you have working there. Bring back the original as monster munch did recently and could not make them fast enough. … Read Full Review
Written on: 22/12/2011
I even sent an email to Nestles in England about this. How could any company take the product they are so well known for and totally destroy it? This seems to be something a lot of companies have done when they take over an existing product. Maybe they think no one notices or cares or maybe there is just so much more profit to be made by using substandard ingredients. I think most people would pay a premium to purchase the original chocolates packaged in the original box from past years… Read Full Review
Written on: 09/09/2011 by janephilippi (1 review written)
My husband of 45 years has always had a soft spot for a box of Black Magic. He was given a box recently and they are all changed, nothing like the lovely chocolates he used to like so much. He loved the soft centers and I liked the toffees and hazelnuts. Nothing for him and none I liked either. Why change something good?… Read Full Review
Written on: 21/08/2011 by luckiangels (1 review written)
Nestle wake up !!! All of your many customers are all but begging you to bring back our much loved Black Magic Chocolates!!! Your competition can not hold a candle against your beautiful chocolates. We love them and want them back!!! Lets get them on the shelve for this Christmas!!! I live in Canmore,AB.,lets make the world a better place with your product back on the shelves. Same box,same recipe . . . please! We are waiting… Read Full Review
Written on: 27/04/2011
What is happening at Nestle???,when I tried these I had to laugh,UTTER RUBBISH,the dark chocolate smell gone,montelimar,butterscoth, the round one with cherry,all gone,other nestles confections they have ruined are fruit pastilles, THEY ALMOST ALL TASTE THE SAME no distinct fruit difference lime used to be very lime, orange very orange,they are now ALL bland shadows of their former glory.And Kit Kat has been ruined by a sickly chocolate that turns slimey in your mouth,who is rumnning this… Read Full Review
Written on: 10/04/2011
What a disappointment! The name 'Classic Collection' couldn't be more inaccurate. Where are the classic Black Magic centres - hazelnut clusters, toffee and mallow, butterscotch, turkish delight, caramel to name but a few?
I was given a large box of BM as a present, but finding the selection so unappetising I took it to a social club which I attend. I actually had difficulty in giving them away - because all those present knew what Black Magic used to be like and were not impressed by the… Read Full Review
Written on: 06/04/2011
Was given Black Magic for mothers' day - and what a disappointment. As other reviews have said, they are NOTHING like original Black Magic! Where is the half moon coffee cream, montelimar, and other original chocs? The ones in the box bear no resemblance in appearance or taste to the 'proper' ones. I think the sales pitch and name is totally misleading… Read Full Review
Written on: 06/04/2011
I agree totally with the reviews, black magic are a real disappointment, all the original centre's
gone, now they are the same as all the other truffle chocs which in my opinion are bland and all taste the same.
Come on nestle you must be reading the reviews.sort it out, I want to see black magic originals centers back on the shelfs.
… Read Full Review
Written on: 26/03/2011 by Steph King (1 review written)
What happened to Black Magic? I thought maybe it was just me until I went looking for reviews and found everybody else asking the same question. Hardly any of the old favourites in there, and what was there was sickly sweet and unpleasant. The box I bought didn't live up to my memories or my expectations, and I note the way the packaging was arranged to make a modest number of chocolates look more generous on the shelf.
I won't be buying them again… Read Full Review
Written on: 18/03/2011 by normamary (1 review written)
My husband bought me a box of Black Magic to cheer me up after a stay in hospital, not easy to find here in Holland ! I was very, very disappointed, never again ! not the chocs I knew and loved . Shame on you Nestle. Gone all the favorite soft centres ! including my favorite ..marzipan..The magic has g
one out of Black Magic, they are just boring, ordinary chocolates.They could at least warned me that they were ..`new improved `..I would have been prepared for the disappointment !… Read Full Review