This was my first night out in Edinburgh as I was visiting my cousin, when we got there everyone got let in expect for me even though I had my drivers license (with photo ID) and my bank card. A blonde woman with glasses was extremely rude and refused to let me in but gave me no reasons as to why. My friends and I will be staying far away from this club due to it having such awful, disrespectful and arrogant staff. DO NOT RECOMMEND!

After my friend and I both loosing our jackets and bags, we phoned silk the following day to see if they had been found. But the woman who answered the call didn't care at all and was very rude, and treated the situation as though they did have our possessions, but didn't care to even look. I found her very ignorant for the whole of the conversation.

Wouldn't even like to give it 1* but unfortunately I have to. It seems to me you have a problem them with your bouncers and not recognising people from their ID's. This should not be something that happens, it is very unprofessional, it is fair enough if a bouncer has to ask another bouncer but when two bouncers feel like they can confirm you are not you when you are you, it comes across as a joke. The bouncer with the beard and his fellow bouncer who he called the guru of recognising ID's clearly do not know what they are doing and this has really disappointed my night! I'm 21 years old and have been in university for three in Cardiff and have never been asked twice for ID and also for another form of ID, I had my bank card to confirm but no other photographic Id which isn't usually required. Sort it out

After paying for the entry and for the cloackroom they literally kicked me off and said that I couldn't go in because I was too drunk. That was absolutly crazy beacuse I was sober, but when I try to explain my point of view they were very rude and didn't care at all about what I was saying. The bodyguard treated me like a danguerous person, and actually I'm a 1.50m girl without any bad intentions. My friends and I had to leave the club even if we had already paid for it. I think it's just a way to get some people out when the club is very crowded and to earn money at the same time. Really horrible and unfair!!!

The staff are extremely rude. The lady "bouncers" and the management are appalling, not letting random girls in because they don't like the look meanwhile they're letting legless girls and guys in. When it came to the male bouncers they happily let us in (so we obviously not that drunk). When I asked why my friend wasn't getting back in, the big female bouncer said "does she always look like that?", to which my reply was yes, my friend does always look like that, she said "I feel sorry for her then". What kind of staff is that? How unprofessional.

I go to silk a lot and usually enjoy my night, but recently I've noticed some of the staff can be arrogant. I got to the entrance with three other friends and we were on guest list. My friend who was first to go in said we were a party of 4 going named the guestlist, my first three friends went in then I paid a fiver and got stamped, but then all of a sudden she stopped me. The girl taking the money then demanded 7 pound and denied that I had given her a fiver before I got stamped. Almost like she had a memory of a gold fish or worse, dory from nemo! I then had to pay 7 pound, not only did I have to pay regular entrance when I was on guest list but had to pay and extra 7 pound on top of the first 5 pound I paid, 12 pound to get in!! Ridiculous, they should hire someone taking the money who can actually count or at least remember the money she's taking in! Anyway, apart from that I enjoy silk, dj is very good, it's popular, hard to get to the bar but that's like that everywhere! The bar staff themselves tend to be very good with dealing with all the people and taking money!

Staff are rude and ignorant, ruined our night out and we left shortly after entering the premises. Avoid at all costs.

The 'club' has 3 levels to it. Each as terrible as the last... Music is the classic rubbish 'club tunes' and staff are not only rude but obnoxious. To be avoided at all costs.. Honestly all costs.

Sorry but i would never recommend this place to anyone as it was one of the worst nights out i have in Edinburgh. I have been to many places in Edinburgh and i must say this is the worst of all. Even though it has been refurbed etc, the atmosphere in silk has not changed from when it was stereo. The floor was all sticky, music was old school & the people were not friendly.